Icefall Pineward 2021

08/04/2022 - 02:35 AM

Top Review

6.5Scent 7Longevity 6Sillage

My dear Icefall, I would

really like to say something nice about you, good thing I didn't read your ingredients in your resume first, so I'm completely unbiased. You are quite an eccentric character, the first impression... well, I hope it's misleading, celery and Maggi herb are your companions. Ah, your name, it's just perfect for hot days, I thought you would cool me down, at least you have an icy character on the outside. Not at all, you are a bit cabbage soup-scented, warming, but take it easy, I'm patient, maybe you're just shy and hiding behind vegetable buddies. Slowly you become calmer, gentler, looking at me kindly, the vegetable herbs turn medicinal, with a pleasant sweetness - just like making gargle solutions tasty for the little ones. And it seems you work in carpentry, you have something woody about you, which I like, it distracts a bit from the cabbage soup. And it feels like I've known you for a while, do you have a brother? Let me check my list, ah, there he is, Kythnos, is he family of yours? Oh no, well then... let's keep it short, you are not my type, I'm sorry, there's not going to be a second date.

Translated · Show original

Palonera 3 years ago

Hmm. I would have expected something different based on the ingredient list. With celery and lovage, I always worry that the scent might have gone off - but according to your description, that impression seems intentional. However, I do enjoy cabbage soup in the fall, but only in a bowl, not on my skin, ;-).

Translated · Show original

SaGa 3 years ago

Well, if you want to shine with cabbage soup, you have to expect a basket 😉

Translated · Show original

Ttfortwo 3 years ago

That's quite a polite rejection, dear Pluto! I didn't even know this brand, let alone this scent existed. And after you dismissed it so expertly, I don't want it either. There!

Translated · Show original

Pluto 3 years ago

I was hoping for something completely different.

Translated · Show original

Ergoproxy 3 years ago

Somehow, I felt that way about the whole brand.

Translated · Show original

Pluto 3 years ago

Good to know, that saves me some trouble😉

Translated · Show original

Kleopatra 3 years ago

I wouldn't even go on a first date with that. And then cabbage soup... yuck!

Translated · Show original

Pluto 3 years ago

Others don't seem to notice the veggie aspect, but it ruins the fun for me; the nice base just isn't enough.

Translated · Show original

MonsieurTest 3 years ago

Don't worry about it,
Here on the big perfume Tinder
You'll quickly have a few new dates... ;-)).

Translated · Show original

Pluto 3 years ago

Exactly, there are already a few applicants here who want to be sniffed out 😉

Translated · Show original

Taurus 3 years ago

That sounds quite unusual... ;-)

Translated · Show original

Pluto 3 years ago

Well, you have to like it to wear it. It gets better after the heart notes 😊

Translated · Show original

DOCBE 3 years ago

In the end, names are just noise and smoke, but I also can't stand it when expectations are raised...

Translated · Show original

Pluto 3 years ago

Exactly, it's so irritating, or rather... disappointing... Are you doing okay, my dear?

Translated · Show original

Gelis 3 years ago

I wouldn't even be willing to wear it on a first date.

Translated · Show original

Pluto 3 years ago

I'm just so curious...

Translated · Show original

FlirtyFlower 3 years ago

You almost tempted me into a cabbage soup diet with your comment =D=D=D Trophy

Translated · Show original

Pluto 3 years ago

Oh wow, that's too monotonous 😉

Translated · Show original

Profuma 3 years ago

With that "pre-loading" pyramid, I wouldn't have even given it a first date :-D! Good thing you wrapped up the story ;-D

Translated · Show original

Pluto 3 years ago

I actually like green notes... actually :o)

Translated · Show original

Schalkerin 3 years ago

I either think Pineward is great or awful. I don't know that one, but I can make you a cabbage soup with Maggi for cheaper ;)

Translated · Show original

Pluto 3 years ago

I'll gladly spoon your Kohl soup 😋

Translated · Show original

Vivaguevara 3 years ago

I actually found it quite refreshing, almost "green-aquatic," and, as one of the few Pineward scents, it was really wearable. However, I tested it in spring, not in the peak of summer. That might have been why I liked it.

Translated · Show original

Pluto 3 years ago

The name is misleading; you expect something refreshing and summery...

Translated · Show original

Floyd 3 years ago

Fragrances can be perceived so differently. For me, it was cooling, fresh, cypress-like, like a mountain panorama... Maybe it was the heat today too...

Translated · Show original

Pluto 3 years ago

That's exactly what I expected from the name😉 unfortunately, that little drop won't be enough for another test in winter.

Translated · Show original

Seta 3 years ago

Vegetal scents seem to be trending right now. It's not for me either.

Translated · Show original

Pluto 3 years ago

I do like it a bit herbal, but this one was too much on the veggie-herbal side for me. It gets better later, but it's only good for a satisfactory rating.

Translated · Show original

Augusto 3 years ago

Icefall sounded so good today. But sweating with vegetable soup, no thanks!

Translated · Show original

Pluto 3 years ago

The name is really not well chosen.

Translated · Show original

0815abc 3 years ago

Haha, Kohl soup, yuck! Flatulence trophy.

Translated · Show original

Pluto 3 years ago

Oh, it wasn't that flatulent 😊 more veggie...

Translated · Show original

Precious 3 years ago

Oh dear, they say that a Maggi scent means a perfume has gone bad. For me, it would be nothing - even without cabbage soup.

Translated · Show original

Pluto 3 years ago

This maggot note is quite common in some herbal scents today.

Translated · Show original

Rundreas 3 years ago

Pineward and the Maggi theme. It's always so misleading. Yes, you can notice the Maggi, but I think the bottle cap smells like it, not the scents themselves...
As for Icefall: It could have been really great. It basically is, but it needs a more fitting name... I imagine something different when I hear Icefall...

Translated · Show original

Pluto 3 years ago

That's true, the name is poorly chosen. I like the base, 6.5 is still a three😉

Translated · Show original

ParfumAholic 3 years ago

I can totally understand that... at the latest with cabbage soup, I would have said goodbye.

Translated · Show original

Pluto 3 years ago

The base saves quite a bit 😉

Translated · Show original

Fittleworth 3 years ago

Very enjoyable review to read. Cabbage soup scent trophy!

Translated · Show original

Pluto 3 years ago

Thank you so much...............

Translated · Show original

Hasi 3 years ago

Why would you put such a soup in such a beautiful bottle?! Ah, the bottle! *sigh*.

Translated · Show original

Pluto 3 years ago

Oh yes, you always have to make compromises.

Translated · Show original

Inger 3 years ago

When I read that, I know I don't even want to test it.

Translated · Show original

Pluto 3 years ago

It's not that bad, no obligation to wash it off.

Translated · Show original

Seejungfrau 3 years ago

What the cabbage soup is to you, a bombastic grapefruit blast is to me.
At the core, pierced by pine needles :)
But I also really like veggie scents.

Translated · Show original

Seejungfrau 3 years ago

No worries :) there’s so much else.

Translated · Show original

Pluto 3 years ago

Really? Wow, I can only perceive grapefruit with a lot of goodwill, what a shame.

Translated · Show original

Seerose 3 years ago

Just reading "algae" makes me shudder. Luckily, I hardly have to eat any. But I don't want to smell all fishy and algae-like either. Here, let me offer you a really delicious fresh sprig of lovage, cut this morning while it was still cool, and then you'll get the real Maggi scent! :-)

Translated · Show original

Seerose 3 years ago

Not for soup! For sniffing and in salads, on herb quark, baguette... Such a sprout is delicate and aromatic.

Translated · Show original

Pluto 3 years ago

Thank you very much, but unfortunately it's too warm for soup today.

Translated · Show original

Gschpusi 3 years ago

Haha, genius...
This one wouldn’t be for me. I still don’t get why scents have to smell like vegetables and especially... WHO wears something like that? Oh wait... chefs.. Exactly, chefs 😂

Translated · Show original

Pluto 3 years ago

Exactly, Mike Süsser. I definitely like him 😊

Translated · Show original

ClarasTante 3 years ago

You have to - when I scroll down... - apparently wear it in winter. Or in spring. Or in autumn. But not in summer, when you’d need ICEFALL. Unpractically done! Cabbage soup in summer. No, just no.

Translated · Show original

Pluto 3 years ago

You should definitely try it in winter.

Translated · Show original

Helena1411 3 years ago

There was once that dreadful cabbage soup diet… I wonder if that served as inspiration…?!

Translated · Show original

Helena1411 3 years ago

That's true, better than smelling like that afterwards ;-)

Translated · Show original

Pluto 3 years ago

Well, I prefer to eat it...

Translated · Show original

Clarissa 3 years ago

Oh wow, the name suggests something fresh, but it's a shame that the ingredients ended up in the soup. 😂

Translated · Show original

Pluto 3 years ago

Yes, that's very unfortunate :o)

Translated · Show original

Gandix 3 years ago

Amusingly written... I actually like it in the heat... And Pineward can definitely do a lot more Maggi 😁

Translated · Show original

Pluto 3 years ago

I'm convinced they can do other things as well; I hope I get to experience that someday.

Translated · Show original

NuiWhakakore 3 years ago

Kohl soup is nasty; he deserved a second chance with the children's medicinal gargle solution...

Translated · Show original

Pluto 3 years ago

Maybe he would have gotten it if there had been just a tiny drop left in it...

Translated · Show original

FrauKirsche 3 years ago

Kohl soup only in connection with Louis de Funès... :))

Translated · Show original

Pluto 3 years ago

Exactly 😊...............

Translated · Show original

Vrabec 3 years ago

I found it quite interesting, Pineward DNA (that's where your Maggi perception comes from) and a pretty cool, minty accord. But I chose a different Pineward :)

Translated · Show original

Pluto 3 years ago

I think I prefer the Chanel DNA :o) But the base is nice, so it gets a 6.5, which is a 3..

Translated · Show original

Pollita 3 years ago

I’d probably feel the same way. Kohl soup doesn’t exactly sound like a favorite fragrance to me 😉

Translated · Show original

Pluto 3 years ago

I prefer it for eating too. :o)

Translated · Show original

Kailani 3 years ago

I don't want to smell like cabbage soup either. Well written with humor. Enjoyed reading it. Best regards!

Translated · Show original

Pluto 3 years ago

Thank you so much, thank goodness the cabbage soup is fading and making way for wood :o)

Translated · Show original