MrPink
04/09/2021 - 02:48 AM
25
6Scent 7Longevity 8Sillage 4Bottle 2Pricing

The Magician and the Con Job

Magician
Noun, masculine [der]
1. someone who possesses magical powers; wizard
2. someone who performs magic tricks, showcases
A magician, also an illusionist or wizard, is an artist of the performing art of magic.

"The art of magic (also known as conjuring and sorcery) describes a form of performing art that understands how to evoke illusions in the minds of viewers and feelings in the hearts of people through artistic communication (verbal and non-verbal) and by using various techniques and methods. The performance is not bound to any specific location or situation. The more willing the viewer is to be enchanted, the greater the illusion can become in their imagination." - Wikipedia

Welcome dear Parfumas and Parfumos, I am the great Duadini and will take you on a journey into a world full of illusions...

Friends, friends, friends - of course, I am not the great Duadini, I am Manuel Neuer.
But jokes aside... Why the long intro? I would like to address a topic that has been on my mind for a long time. Namely, how Dua manages to create the illusion of a good fragrance.
As should be known by now, Dua primarily copies fragrances from well-known niche and designer brands. Especially through what is called reverse engineering.

"Reverse engineering (English; German: umgekehrt entwickeln, rekonstruieren, abbreviation: RE; also Nachkonstruktion) refers to the process of extracting the construction elements from an existing finished system or a product that is mostly industrially manufactured by examining the structures, states, and behaviors. Thus, a plan is created again from the finished object." - Wikipedia

This is done by hunting down the fragrance using an analysis tool (probably a mass spectrometer or something similar, I'm not a chemist) and then having the exact composition aka the recipe.
Now, the goal is to create as exact a replica of the original creation as possible with the "original" recipe while eliminating any potential performance weaknesses. Should be doable, right?
For Bois Oudh, the classic and beautiful scent Oud Wood clearly served as a model.

So, has DUA succeeded in this illusion? - Sort of. Only with trick 17!
Because, although DUA has the exact composition, I believe there are subtle differences concerning the choice of raw materials. It should be noted that Tom Ford is also not particularly known for using the finest raw materials, but rather for creations that often balance on the fine line of provocation.
But back to DUA: What is the most important discipline of a magician? Right - distraction!
And DUA does this well, using power to distract. This fragrance starts off incredibly potent, filling the entire room, even the whole floor. This certainly makes an impression and suggests quality, but with an extrait, you expect that too, right? In my opinion, however, the nose is overwhelmed early on, to such an extent that the fine nuances, the qualitative differences, become hardly recognizable over time. It's a bit like overly spicy food! (Sriracha, for example, also helps with bad university cafeteria food!)
No question - Bois Oudh smells very much like Oud Wood, especially in the sillage. But does it smell just as elegant, so fine, so perfectly woven and coordinated? No, not at all!!!
For me, Bois Oudh also comes across, independent of Oud Wood - as a standalone fragrance - coarse, unrefined, and synthetic. It masks the (inferior) raw materials and overwhelms the noses with a barrage of olfactory impressions. When I smell closely, I always perceive a certain mineral oil note. It smells "cheap" and imperfect. It is loud and potent. A loudmouth, without finesse. Brutal power without fine-tuning. A souped-up tractor, not a Ferrari. But for a layperson and occasional perfume wearer, it is still an experience!

Especially when trying other (clone) creations (e.g., Roja, MFK, Xerjoff) from DUA, this illusion as a sales strategy becomes particularly clear - but that's another topic.
Bois Oudh (and the company DUA) is a bride in combat boots. A wolf in sheep's clothing. An illusionist par excellence. A magician. And a very good one, as I admit I was enchanted for a while.

Is this fragrance supposed to be one of the best 25 fragrances for men? - Nah bruh! U must be trippin!
Translated · Show originalShow translation
11 Comments
AxiomaticAxiomatic 4 years ago
Thanks for the insights into Dua's company culture. I wasn't familiar with the brand before.
Translated · Show originalShow translation
AlexxxAlexxx 4 years ago
Very well and accurately described. It gives me a headache. Disappointing Dua.
Translated · Show originalShow translation
ExUserExUser 5 years ago
2
Interesting description and the review too. I'm currently testing it as well, and so far it's even weaker than the original, which is already quite weak.
Translated · Show originalShow translation
ChizzaChizza 5 years ago
I'm more into the originals too, and I see the current prevailing strategy as very negative.
Translated · Show originalShow translation
Can777Can777 5 years ago
Very successful and nuanced comment that I read with great interest. Personally, I would prefer the original. Either way!
Translated · Show originalShow translation
ViseronViseron 5 years ago
Great comment on an interesting topic. The fact that Dua always emphasizes that it's an **EXTRAIT DE PARFUM** definitely adds to the illusion that you're dealing with a high-quality creation.
But we've talked about that a lot privately.
I think the hype will eventually die down. The motto "Performance at any cost" is, in my opinion, a fundamentally wrong direction.
Translated · Show originalShow translation
VrabecVrabec 5 years ago
1
Hmm, I’ve only had one Dua so far, and that was by chance, plus I didn’t know the original either. Your comment, though, is making me a bit skeptical about this dupe brand :D Maybe I’ll do a direct comparison test.
Translated · Show originalShow translation
SoapSoap 5 years ago
A very good comment :-) I also notice the mineral oil note; but I think Tom Ford has his fragrances made "only" by big chemists at Givaudan and the like. It's not the ingredients that are special here, but the unique chemical compounds that are developed and patented, then sold as "Tom Ford." It's kind of disillusioning in a way. In this context, what DUA does is essentially no different. I like it..
Translated · Show originalShow translation
BastianBastian 5 years ago
It's definitely good.
Translated · Show originalShow translation
ExUserExUser 5 years ago
Dua really benefits from the growing obsession with performance and power, which is sometimes fueled by certain YouTube channels. Since the original from TF is more than enough for me in terms of "performance," Dua doesn't win me over here. However, Dua does have a few good ones beyond the "mass appeal" and "crowd pleaser" ;)
Translated · Show originalShow translation
OldfactiveOldfactive 5 years ago
I've also smelled 3 dupes from DUA so far. The dupes for Oud Minerale, Tobacco Oud, and this Oud Wood dupe. They're all close, but as mentioned, they fail to perfectly replicate the original scent. So I can't really get into the brand and prefer to stick with the originals.
Translated · Show originalShow translation