PoorRichard

Imagine this: you’re parked in a lounge chair, toes in the sand, frozen margarita in hand, and your phone’s somewhere you can’t hear it. That’s the vibe St. Barts gives off right out of the gate. It kicks off with a fizzy burst of lime and a splash of tequila (yes, really), then mellows into a breeze of salt air and sweet guava. No deep woods or moody spices here. It’s light, fun, a little boozy, and doesn’t take itself too seriously. Sure, it won’t last all day, but neither does happy hour. Just toss it in your beach bag and re-up when the sun hits noon.

THE BREAKDOWN:
Scent: 8/10 — Bright, zesty, tropical cocktail energy. Perfect for sun and sand.
Versatility: 7/10 — Best for summer and laid-back settings. Save it for beach days, BBQs, or backyard escapes.
Performance: 6.5/10 — Strong start but fades fast. You’ll want a backup spritz nearby.
Value: 8.5/10 — You can usually find it cheap, and for a scent that smells like vacation in a bottle, that’s a win.

Davidoff Cool Water Intense doesn’t smell like the OG, and that’s the point. Gone is the crisp, aquatic barbershop vibe of the OG. In its place, you get something deeper, darker, and moodier, more “midnight swim” than “morning splash.” It opens with a bold, almost juicy green mandarin that quickly dives into rich amber and a velvety coconut nectar note that feels more ocean dusk than beach cocktail. There’s a smooth, almost inky quality to it, like deep blue water lit by moonlight. It’s Cool Water reimagined for evening wear: sleek, modern, and more confident. Same name, different energy.

* Scent: 9/10 – Deep, blue, and unexpectedly warm with a tropical undercurrent
* Performance: 8/10 – Lasts well, with moderate projection and a smooth drydown
* Versatility: 8/10 – Best for evenings, date nights, or cooler summer days
* Value: 8.5/10 – A bold twist on a classic for a very fair price