Fetish pour Homme vs Alexandria II vs Carlisle: fall/winter

Friends, please help to select among Fetish pour Homme vs Alexandria II vs Carlisle. Please indicate your choice and elaborate on the main criteria for your selection. I believe they are all good performers, the rest is still unclear. Your opinions would be highly welcome. 

Sorry, I only know Carlisle.   It is too vanilla-heavy for daily use. For me.

I only know Alexandria II. It's beautiful but very strong.  

This is good to my ears, you know i like them strong and is one of the samples i ordered