Foustie:
Perfumers Workshop Tea Rose. It's a huge honking Rose Soliflore. I can't quite believe how cheap it is.
+1 on this one. It is one of my mother's personal favorites, so I bulk buy for her at TJ Maxx, Marshall's, or when it's on sale online.
Another vote for
Tabac Original Great stuff that lasts and lasts.
Aqua Quorum Kind of like a cross between Wings for Men and Polo Sport, but unlike either, I actually like this one. Goes all day on my skin and is a great summer fragrance.
Everlast Original 1910 by Everlast. Starts off citrusy like so many sporty, athletic fragrances, and then surprisingly, dries down into a rather beautiful woody Oriental.
Avon Wild CountryClean(in an old school sense), barber shop type fragrance. Can be had for $10 or less on sale, lasts very well for a cologne, and smells far better than people give it credit for.
Perry Ellis 360 Degrees White Definitely a JPG Le Male Vibe going on but not so cloyingly intense as the original.
Cuba Gold and the now discontinued
Javari by The Body Shop all fall under this category.
Cuba Royale Poor man's Paco Rabanne 1 Million, except I actually like the Cuba Royale
Santa Fe Smells shockingly similar to The 3rd Man by Caron...not as complex or intense, but certainly nice at the $2 a bottle I spent for mine. Worth a blind buy if you can find it cheap nowadays.
Canoe EDT I do not bother with the cologne strength, but the EDT is a fresh lemony burst, along with lavender and vanilla to back it up. Lasts as well as anything out there, and I finally understood the attraction and all the magazine fanfare back in the day after sampling this strength.
Old Spice No, it doesn't smell as good as it did when made by Shulton, but it still smells darned good and it's a pretty safe bet for a good cheapie.