How do you vote - old vs current formula?
9 years ago
When I come to vote on a perfume's longevity, sillage, rating I often find myself in a quandry.
Easy enough when it is a new perfume because I just vote for that but what to do when reviewing a perfume of long -standing e.g. Poison?
Old Poison = five star longevity, sillage, rating.
New Poison = a bit less than that.
I was really takenaback when I compared the version from a year ago with the version from a few years before that.
In the review I can say which version I am reviewing but the voting is a different matter.
What do you do? Do you vote according to the version you have even though not available; do you not vote at all because it might be misleading?
Hmmm.
Easy enough when it is a new perfume because I just vote for that but what to do when reviewing a perfume of long -standing e.g. Poison?
Old Poison = five star longevity, sillage, rating.
New Poison = a bit less than that.
I was really takenaback when I compared the version from a year ago with the version from a few years before that.
In the review I can say which version I am reviewing but the voting is a different matter.
What do you do? Do you vote according to the version you have even though not available; do you not vote at all because it might be misleading?
Hmmm.
Last edited by DorothyGrace on 02.09.2015, 20:41; edited 1 time in total