...I think it's a big mistake to take the word of any one person that a possible reformulation (as when bottle designs change or a company is sold off) is nearly identical to the original. Andre's opinion about Dior Homme is way off, IMO, for example. If I don't wear certain types of scents often, I know that I don't have the same understanding of those as I do ones that I do, and anyone who claims to be able to detect minute differences in any and every type of scent raises red flags to me. I think Andre is sincere and believes his assessment is accurate, but the only way you will know if his opinion works for you is if you sample for yourself.