this does have a resemblance with moulin rouge by histoires des parfums on my skin, sharing the same fruited orris, slightly rosy and cosmetic notes. i would say this opens with a more intense powdery note; where the histoires has a more plummy-cinnamon inflection, here the raspberry is more a facet of the orris on my skin that comes in and out with a sour note. incarnata also goes in a more soft suede-like direction as it wears, wrapping around a mildly spicy and dry-ambery note, as opposed to the histoires powdered muskiness. still both fairly close in their overall presentation to my nose though. still, i love this cosmetic powder-cosiness. do i need both? maybe.