Log in

Monocle Scent Three: Sugi by Comme des Garçons

Monocle Scent Three: Sugi 2013

Yatagan
03/22/2014 - 10:00 AM
52
Top Review
9Scent 5Longevity 5Sillage 10Bottle

Zen - Japanese Fragrance Ceremony

Surely not coincidentally, the symbol of the internet/magazine Monocle, which is embossed on the packaging of the three Monocle fragrances by Comme des Garçons, corresponds to the Enso (Japanese for "circle"), which embodies emptiness and completion in Zen Buddhism and serves as a metaphor and symbol of Zen.

In contrast to classical religions, Zen does not offer an actual doctrine, no clear answers to questions, but it can help to resolve the confusions created by the never-silent voices of our thoughts and our illusion of a "self".

It seems to me that with Sugi, the ideal connection between Japanese aesthetics and European perfume tradition has been achieved. The clarity, simplicity, and radicality of the fragrance, without complex philosophical overtones, has none of the Catholic-Baroque solemnity of many fragrances, none of the floral playfulness of European garden tradition, and none of the melting sweetness of Arabic-opulent scents. The fragrance is reduced to the essentials, is fragrance in itself; seen this way, it is closer to Zen tradition than most other fragrances I know.

In analogy to the Zen-dedicated Japanese tea ceremony, I offer here a suggestion for the appropriate enjoyment of Sugi.

Prepare the fragrance. At first, do not pay attention to it. Be completely yourself.

Wander through nature. Prepare yourself for the enjoyment of the fragrance by shedding the everyday. This takes you to the first stage of enlightenment.

Retreat with the fragrance into a quiet room that grants you the necessary calmness. Turn inward.

Once again, turn to nature, even if only by looking out of the open window.

Avoid any haste when testing the fragrance.

Ensure that you are cleansed both internally and externally. Wash your hands and face again if necessary. Make sure that no other scents distract your concentration on the essentials.

Sit down in the Japanese seiza position. Find your calm. Leave your restlessness behind.

If you feel hungry, light foods are ideal for preparation: fruits and raw vegetables.

Place the fragrance before you, open it without haste. Focus on the scent.

Spray Sugi on your cleansed skin, particularly suitable is the surface of the forearms with their fine hairs.

Wait a short while.

When you now smell the fragrance, treat it with respect. Take your time in your judgment.

What do you smell? I do not know what YOU smell, but I smell something that closely resembles the successful description in the comment below: the alcoholic sharpness of gin, which initially dominates the fragrance development.
Then coniferous notes (pine and/or cypress, with the latter seeming to be dominant).

The pepper indicated in the fragrance notes is rather present through a certain sharpness. The tingling that pepper occasionally evokes in the top notes of some fragrances is only subtly perceptible here, while the alcoholic sharpness does not dissolve from the fragrance and accompanies the wearer, who, like most CdGs, hardly experiences any significant development.
Floral elements remain discreet and underlying.

The woody note, which is also recognizable from the beginning, corresponds to the faint yet perceptible scent of hard, dried wood, less so that of freshly cut or rotten, moldy wood; nor that characteristic forest scent, which blends with green plant notes. The wood tone remains cool, dry, elegant. The image of gin in a turned wooden cup from the aforementioned comment seems to me ideally fitting.
I also feel somewhat reminded of the wood in front of our fireplace, which fills the room with a consciously barely perceptible yet present wood note that one would only notice if the wood were no longer there, if the presence were filled by an emptiness.

However, one should not be deceived by this description: Sugi is not a quiet fragrance. Sugi has character and is a clear statement with which many, both men and women, surroundings and wearers, will not feel comfortable.

Moreover, Sugi is not a fragrance that reveals itself casually. Zen offers no simple answers. Zen is life, meditation, immersion, concentration. This principle is embodied by the fragrance better than any other.
The approach described above is not meant ironically. It is appropriate to the fragrance in its aesthetic clarity.
Translated · Show originalShow translation
27 Comments
Flakon11eFlakon11e 1 year ago
wonderful understanding of this extraordinary and rather subtle fragrance 🌱
Translated · Show originalShow translation
YataganYatagan 1 year ago
Thank you! ☺️ 🙏
Translated · Show originalShow translation
ChizzaChizza 5 years ago
Great comment! I see the whole line as stripped down to the essentials, which I really like, but it doesn't tempt me to make a purchase.
Translated · Show originalShow translation
Andre19283Andre19283 8 years ago
I ordered it today after a long testing phase and great enthusiasm. Partly also because of your comment. Thanks for that! :)
Translated · Show originalShow translation
SeejungfrauSeejungfrau 8 years ago
Strong comment! Not an easy fragrance, but very special. I can relate to that with tea.
Translated · Show originalShow translation
JensemannJensemann 9 years ago
Sounds good! I'll keep it in mind!
Translated · Show originalShow translation
Zauber600Zauber600 10 years ago
Very inspired comment, the scent seems to be something for me. Namastè Yatagan :)
Translated · Show originalShow translation
YallaYalla 11 years ago
You described the wood note particularly well and understandably. The scent comes across very clearly to me, but it feels more masculine.
Translated · Show originalShow translation
KiengiraKiengira 11 years ago
I agree with Maren! There's nothing more to say!!!! Looking forward to WI!
Translated · Show originalShow translation
KaschimaKaschima 11 years ago
A purple Fukusa for you, so you can test even more and leave such lovely comments!
Translated · Show originalShow translation
UnterholzUnterholz 11 years ago
This great comment definitely deserves a trophy! Yes, that's how perfumes should generally be tested...
Translated · Show originalShow translation
GaukeleyaGaukeleya 11 years ago
Wonderful! That's what I'll do when I come across it :-) Maybe we should generally approach fragrances this way *thinking*
Translated · Show originalShow translation
0815abc0815abc 11 years ago
You write wonderfully. The calm space that grants us serenity is within ourselves. A trophy for beauty and depth for you.
Translated · Show originalShow translation
DobbsDobbs 11 years ago
It seems to me that this fragrance rightly belongs on my wishlist. It will be the first test candidate during my next visit to Düsseldorf.
Translated · Show originalShow translation
AmyAmyAmyAmy 11 years ago
I really like your comment, and the fragrance too. I'm just waiting for my chosen perfume shop to finally get it in stock...
Translated · Show originalShow translation
AuraAura 11 years ago
Your comment also deserves the utmost respect, but I just wondered what it would be like to test fragrances while expanded in consciousness, I mean, high ;o) Ommmmm.....
Translated · Show originalShow translation
IngerInger 11 years ago
Yes, that's how I should test the fragrances too!! I don't know this scent, though. Wonderful!!
Translated · Show originalShow translation
PlutoPluto 11 years ago
I find your "test tips" applicable to life as well, not just limited to fragrances!
Translated · Show originalShow translation
DannyboyDannyboy 11 years ago
:D Looks like someone got caught! I really like it too, but the acidity... hmm, we'll see. Is it just me, or does no one else smell anything citrusy or fruity?^^
Translated · Show originalShow translation
PaloneraPalonera 11 years ago
"When you smell the fragrance, treat it with respect. Take your time with your judgment." One of the most important statements in this comment, the most important statement overall, for approaching a fragrance properly and wanting to evaluate it.
Translated · Show originalShow translation
ZoraZora 11 years ago
I'm already feeling relaxed just reading this :). It would be great for many fragrances, but also just in everyday life.
Translated · Show originalShow translation
ShamisShamis 11 years ago
It doesn't sound ironic either. I really like your suggestion on how to optimally test the fragrance. It's completely different from the hasty spray-spray tests in the perfume department. As always, wonderfully described, thank you!
Translated · Show originalShow translation
SensualSensual 11 years ago
Your suggestion for proper testing would also fit well for many others; it could be a "Sticky" in the "how to properly test fragrances" thread or something like that. ;) Again, so well written that it makes you want to test it out. Trophy!
Translated · Show originalShow translation
ErgoproxyErgoproxy 11 years ago
I told you it's great! :)
Translated · Show originalShow translation
MeggiMeggi 11 years ago
Beautiful! Thank you!
Translated · Show originalShow translation
FittleworthFittleworth 11 years ago
Thank you very much! Domo arigato gozaimasu! A Zen trophy for you...
Translated · Show originalShow translation
TaurusTaurus 11 years ago
ZENsational ;-)
Translated · Show originalShow translation