Log in

Create Account Forgot your Password?
NicheOnly
05/22/2025 - 07:52 AM
7
Very helpful Review
5Scent 5Longevity 5Sillage 6Bottle 4Pricing

Predictable throughout

If anybody reading this is still expecting big things from Parfums de Marly in 2025 then I don't know what to tell you. The brand has no recent history to showcase they're capable of launching anything with even mild originality. With Castley, I feel like the truth lies somewhere in the middle.

Castley opens fresh, slightly fruity & woody. In my notes, I have written that the contrast of accords is somewhat in the realm of Ex Nihilo's "Blue Talisman | Ex Nihilo" as the scent clearly has a Bisch-esque (i.e. perfumer Quentin Bisch) signature to it, implying the use of akigalawood (listed in the base notes). The scent has some fizzy feel, but up-close smells mostly fresh spicy and woody with implied light florals. The ginger opposes these accords more moderately, pushing the structure towards the realm of scents like Ex Nihilo's The Hedonist Extrait de Parfum. Throughout the wear there is a light fizzy feel which does have a similar-ish style to the way it is executed in Sedley, but given the overt spiciness & woodiness, it is not the best overall comparison to be reaching for.

Relative to the accords voted on by other Parfumo users, I don't get anything citrusy with this fragrance. The scent is fresh, spicy and woody with a light fruitiness implied from the ginger. The various peppers and the akigalawood are the leading notes. Within Parfums de Marly's catalogue, the scent offers key accord overlap with both Galloway and Shagya. Needless to say, Castley doesn't smell similar to either, albeit the structure itself is simple and definitely something befitting of the Parfums de Marly name on the fresher end of their catalogue.

As it relates to the performance, my initial impressions are that the scent is light-to-average. Sillage appears to be within arms length or just above, I am initially guesstimating around 6 hours of longevity. In terms of value, I feel like Castley is a better value proposition than Ex Nihilo's extraits line, esp. given better grey market availability, but that simultaneously doesn't mean much with PDM retail now at €270/125ml. Utility wise better suited for spring as the core dry-down is entirely structured on a fresh spicy & woody DNA. Overall, not the worst I've seen from Marly over the last handful of years, but nothing worthy of strictly positive coverage either.
Updated on 05/22/2025
3 Comments
ShantaySprayShantaySpray 1 year ago
1
Castley relies on much more (uninteresting) ambroxan than Blue Talisman, but the latter has much more tropical fruit whereas Castley is much more citrus.
CeesieCeesie 1 year ago
3
No need to rush out the door then to sniff it. Thanks for the review!
NicheOnlyNicheOnly 1 year ago
1
Any time. Valaya Exclusif and Pacific Rock Flower will be next.