I sampled Peach's Revenge a while back and really loved it, but after reading reviews I decided to sample Pastel Rumours and Rococo Pie, along with Peach Macaron. The idea was to only purchase the one I loved the most. Rococo Pie was the only I really disliked
Pastel Rumours is a gorgeous, creamy, candy, peach/vanilla yogurt fragrance. Im really glad I can’t smell the cardamom in this. It does smell quite similar to Peach's Revenge, although I think this is the more versatile, safe, mass appealing, easier to wear option. I love it! This is the one I’d probably get the most wear out of.
Peach's Revenge is memorable and made a lasting impression on me. It’s a gorgeous, more unique and complex candied Peach, Guava, vanilla and cinnamon/amaretto scent. I do sometimes get a bit of a mustiness in the dry down, which I guess is the peach/cinnamon combo, but due to this I do have to be in the mood to wear it. I was really captivated by the Guava note though, which is 10/10 to die for! It gives the scent that little something special and made it a real struggle to decide which one I liked more. I love Peach's Revenge for its uniqueness, and it lasts the longest, but I honestly couldn’t decide.
Peach Macaron is ok, but my least favourite. It’s similar to Pastel Rumours, but I feel Pastel Rumours is higher quality. I didn’t find Peach Macaroon particularly unique and actually thought it was a bit harsh and screechy. The longevity on me is also poor, so this was a definite no.
Conclusion - Both Pastel Rumours and Peach's Revenge are stunning scents and absolute loves! They are both high quality, project and are long lasting. If you have one, you really don’t need the other. I just couldn’t choose a favourite between them and had to have them both. I’ve even been layering them. Out of my full collection these are my current favourite scents!
