We may earn a commission when you buy from links on our site, including the eBay Partner Network and Amazon.

Minuit à New York 1998

6.9 / 10 19 Ratings
A perfume by Gloria Vanderbilt for men, released in 1998. The scent is spicy-woody. The production was apparently discontinued.
Compare
Similar fragrances
We may earn a commission when you buy from links on our site, including the eBay Partner Network and Amazon.

Main accords

Spicy
Woody
Fresh
Earthy
Citrus

Fragrance Pyramid

Top Notes Top Notes
OrangeOrange GrapefruitGrapefruit LemonLemon
Heart Notes Heart Notes
VetiverVetiver Black pepperBlack pepper PatchouliPatchouli PelargoniumPelargonium
Base Notes Base Notes
LeatherLeather SmokeSmoke BenzoinBenzoin OakmossOakmoss
Ratings
Scent
6.919 Ratings
Longevity
5.915 Ratings
Sillage
5.715 Ratings
Bottle
5.221 Ratings
Submitted by Michael · last update on 06/29/2020.
Source-backed & verified

Smells similar

What the fragrance is similar to
Terre d'Hermès (Eau de Toilette) by Hermès
Terre d'Hermès Eau de Toilette
Terre d'Hermès (Parfum) by Hermès
Terre d'Hermès Parfum

Reviews

3 in-depth fragrance descriptions
Sammler86

15 Reviews
Translated · Show originalShow translation
Sammler86
Sammler86
5  
Terre d'Hermès for Twenty Bucks
Actually, I wanted to write this comment last weekend when I tested The Hero, but unfortunately, I’m only getting around to it now and have to write a bit from memory.

In any case, I visited a good friend, and while we were sitting on his couch looking at his latest artworks that he had created using 3D printing, I noticed that he smelled like Terre d'Hermès. I was quite surprised, as this guy is not at all a connoisseur of niche fragrances and still wears Le Male or its dupes when he goes out. Moreover, he belongs to the type of person who exhibits an anti-brand attitude and would never pay for the name of a product. So, I tried to tease him a bit, "I know what perfume you're wearing, and I know how much it costs...". In hindsight, I kick myself for this statement because it only reinforces his anti-brand stance, and I will probably be teased by him in the future about what I spend my money on.
The situation even threatened to escalate because I initially didn’t believe him that it was a perfume from Rossmann that cost 15 euros - luckily, we hadn’t made a bet. After he showed me the bottle, it slowly became clear to me that it was a rather blatant copy of TdH. The color of the liquid, the shape of the bottle, the Hermès orange appearing on the label, and even the head of the Spartan somehow directly reminded me of Hermès or TdH.

I then generously sprayed myself on the left forearm before driving home, and when I arrived home, I performed the same procedure (though a bit more sparingly) with TdH on the right forearm.

The top note is the biggest difference between the two. While TdH smells herbaceous-earthy, The Hero is more sweet-earthy. Over time, TdH also becomes a bit sweeter, so The Hero captures the heart note of TdH relatively well. Surprisingly, the sillage and longevity of The Hero are also a bit better, although that might also be due to the different dosage. To be honest, I actually prefer the subtle sillage of TdH as it is more pleasant. TdH is one of those fragrances that I wear for myself, one of my signature scents for the office.

The Hero is currently not available and is also not listed in the La Rive online shop. In response to an initial inquiry, I was told that the fragrance (contrary to the information here on Parfumo) is no longer being produced. It's a shame, really, because for 15 euros, you couldn't go wrong. While the price difference isn’t as significant as between Oud Wood and FM335, this dupe is very high quality and, in my opinion, worth significantly more than 15 euros. I would have bought it, but I probably would have gotten TdH again anyway. Just as I will probably end up buying Oud Wood again, because they are never a 1:1 copy, and the original always has something fascinating in it that you don’t want to miss. Moreover, I feel a desire to pay my respects to the creator. Copying is not a great art. Still, the prices of the creators are quite cheeky when you see that it can be done significantly cheaper.
3 Comments
8.5Scent
Agathon81

8 Reviews
Translated · Show originalShow translation
Agathon81
Agathon81
Top Review 6  
Synthetic Terre Substitute for Work
I bought this scent without knowing who or what Jean Claude Ellena is; it was simply cheap and summer, and I had some time to kill at a subway station in Kiev.
Just as Paris is to Kiev, Terre is the unmistakable model for the hero, but it starts off much more alcoholic and drier, lacking the nuance of the layered orange or, as Ellena says, the orange-grapefruit blend. Here, it transitions dryly into the vetiver, which has no citrus or grassy notes, but also isn’t pencil gray like with Tom Ford or Guerlain counterparts. All in all, it’s a good substitute if you don’t want to show off in the office. The differences only become apparent in a head-to-head duel between the two, and inexperienced noses (my roommates) often prefer La Rive on paper. The longevity is slightly below the original at 6-7 hours, but for the price, reapplying shouldn’t hurt. The only thing that keeps me from reaching for it more often is the knowledge of the copy and the missing twist that the grapefruit-orange provides in the original, which makes me only grab it for work... and I bet that with distance and in passing, the difference is hardly noticeable. I don’t want to argue about the pros and cons of cloning; for the price, you get an overall good scent that can appeal to you even if you’re not a perfume enthusiast or know nothing about the original. And even then, it has its own character that surpasses mainstream scents like Malle or One Million in terms of understatement and style, which is surely what Ellena was aiming for in some way... Craftsmanship instead of avant-garde: mass production replaces l’art pour l’art... how one evaluates this societal trend is left to each individual. I would recommend to the defenders of originality the dictum of Pasolini, who knew long before Bourdieu that every aesthetic judgment also has a moral-social dimension.
3 Comments
1Scent
Ferox

4 Reviews
Translated · Show originalShow translation
Ferox
Ferox
2  
Not for lovers of sweet and soft scents
So I got this because I liked the description and there were no comments about it. Unfortunately, I am very disappointed because it just smells unpleasant to me, and with such a scent, you can only be a hero who causes villains (and all other people) to flee due to the olfactory nuisance.
It is supposed to be a masculine scent, but with this fragrance, all I can think of is an old grandpa sitting comfortably in his herb shop, enjoying the day.

My first impression: I am visiting this aforementioned grandpa!
I can't detect lemon, orange, or grapefruit in the first seconds.
Even after several minutes, only the smell of herbs remains, which reminds me a bit of a steam bath where the air has been infused with herbs. Furthermore, the perfume strongly reminds me of incense sticks and slightly of church incense.

Conclusion: I have used it once so far and will try to give it away or just throw it away.
3 Comments

Charts

This is how the community classifies the fragrance.
Pie Chart Radar Chart

Popular by Gloria Vanderbilt

Vanderbilt (Eau de Toilette) by Gloria Vanderbilt Minuit à New York by Gloria Vanderbilt Jardin à New York by Gloria Vanderbilt Miss Vanderbilt by Gloria Vanderbilt Fatale by Gloria Vanderbilt Vanderbilt in Red by Gloria Vanderbilt Honeymoon by Gloria Vanderbilt Eau de Luxe by Gloria Vanderbilt Rêverie by Gloria Vanderbilt Vanderbilt (Eau de Parfum) by Gloria Vanderbilt Vanderbilt (Parfum) by Gloria Vanderbilt V (Eau de Toilette) by Gloria Vanderbilt Vanderbilt Sensations - Rose Harmony by Gloria Vanderbilt Eau de Vanderbilt by Gloria Vanderbilt Love for Love by Gloria Vanderbilt Glorious (Eau de Toilette) by Gloria Vanderbilt Little Gloria by Gloria Vanderbilt Vanderbilt Woman by Gloria Vanderbilt Sensation de Glace / Icy Sensation by Gloria Vanderbilt Rêverie Pure by Gloria Vanderbilt Vanderbilt Sensations - Lily Vitality by Gloria Vanderbilt