Black Collection

Well-Behaved Women Seldom Make History 2009

Well-Behaved Women Seldom Make History by Vintner's Reserve
We may earn a commission when you buy from links on our site, including the eBay Partner Network and Amazon.
8.2 / 10 161 Ratings
A popular perfume by Vintner's Reserve for women and men, released in 2009. The scent is sweet-spicy. It is still in production.
We may earn a commission when you buy from links on our site, including the eBay Partner Network and Amazon.

Main accords

Sweet
Spicy
Oriental
Creamy
Woody

Fragrance Pyramid

Top Notes Top Notes
LimeLime Green notesGreen notes PepperPepper ZimthoplaxZimthoplax
Heart Notes Heart Notes
SandalwoodSandalwood JasmineJasmine VioletViolet
Base Notes Base Notes
AmberAmber Tonka beanTonka bean VanillaVanilla ZalkribtulZalkribtul

Perfumers

Ratings
Scent
8.2161 Ratings
Longevity
7.5148 Ratings
Sillage
7.1146 Ratings
Bottle
7.4140 Ratings
Value for money
4.6128 Ratings
Submitted by OPomone, last update on 04/02/2025.
Interesting Facts
The fragrance is part of the "Black Collection" collection.

Smells similar

What the fragrance is similar to
Club Black (Eau de Toilette) by Mercedes-Benz
Club Black Eau de Toilette
Eau des Missions by Le Couvent
Eau des Missions
Spiritueuse Double Vanille by Guerlain
Spiritueuse Double Vanille
Arabians Tonka by Montale
Arabians Tonka
Althaïr by Parfums de Marly
Althaïr
Blessed Baraka by Initio
Blessed Baraka

Reviews

6 in-depth fragrance descriptions
Myrtillajus

529 Reviews
Myrtillajus
Myrtillajus
1  
A deep journey
A deep journey, the inspiration is from the seven seas, which in my opinion hides something more, however.
Dark Amber is a deep, sensual, enveloping fragrance that opens immediately with an indolic and creamy floral part, overwhelmed by the relaxing effect of sandalwood.
Then the deep scents of amber and realistic vanilla pods emerge, of the highest quality, which really balances the composition.
It is warm, sensual, a cuddle especially for the colder seasons.
Excellent sillage and longevity.
‘Winter sunset’ painted by Choultsè.
0 Comments
4
Pricing
9
Bottle
6
Sillage
6
Longevity
8
Scent
Mad91

3 Reviews
Translated Show original Show translation
Mad91
Mad91
3  
Beautiful fragrance with moderate sillage and half-life at the moon price
Top note:
In the top note Dark Amber starts very nice dark-heavy, resinous and for me personally sweetish-malty. The sweetish smell part reminds me of malt beer - and in a very nice elegant whiteness and in no way cheap.
Over the course of the next 10 minutes, the fragrance DNA from the top note remains largely intact, but the scent turns quite quickly from the initially heavy character to a lighter olfactory image. Unfortunately, this is also accompanied by a reduction of the sillage, which was initially very nice present.

Transition to the heart note:
With the lighter become the fragrance one recognizes then spicy chords.

Base note:
In the base note comes with me then already after 20 minutes the jasmine more and more to the fore and the fragrance develops increasingly in a woodier direction, whereby the sweet-malty aroma more and more in the background and is accompanied by a more vanilla aroma. Also violets I take then clearly war.

Sillage: After an hour, the sillage has unfortunately decreased sharply and the fragrance is only perceptible close to the skin
Durability: After just under 6 hours, the scent is then no longer perceptible.

Conclusion:
Beautiful fragrance character especially at the beginning. Unfortunately, only moderate sillage and mediocre durability. For the price of over 400€ which is required I will not buy this fragrance.
1 Comment
7
Pricing
9
Bottle
7
Sillage
8
Longevity
10
Scent
TunikaMIRO

19 Reviews
Translated Show original Show translation
TunikaMIRO
TunikaMIRO
Helpful Review 3  
Good work Mr. Bonneville
.... It's now been six months since my niche fragrance journey with YOU began. I heard about you, tested you in KaDeWe and was blown away at the first sniff. Your golden eyes, your warm, creamy ambery tail had me in stitches, but I was still a little green behind the ears. I didn't see your true sensual beauty next to the dragon conquerors and bodybuilders like Ombre Nomade. Sure, you were beautiful, incredibly beautiful, but still a little reserved in your appearance. I didn't realize your intention at the time, that sometimes silence is golden. You don't have ADHD, you don't have to talk much and prefer to observe, but you still seduce those who come close to you. Now I know that elegance doesn't have to be intrusive. You act in the background and yet you are incredibly self-confident and still somehow there. I had to have you back then, bought you, and on my further journey you got a little lost in my wardrobe next to all the beasts and we parted ways. I never got over it and when I gained more knowledge I ventured back to Ku'damm and bought you a second time. The job of an amber fragrance is not to fill entire concert halls. It is not in your interest to stand in the middle and shout that you are there and that people should please pay attention to you. You, my dear Dark Amber, are incredibly beautiful just the way you are. Everyone around you notices you, but not over 300 meters away. A partner will notice you for an incredibly long time, I will also notice you for a long time and others will also recognize you in the open air and be seduced by your beauty.

Mr. Bonneville has done a great job with this perfume and it is not without reason that he is the most popular Birkholz. As I just described, amber fragrances are seen the wrong way from my point of view and I was like that at the beginning. They are not screamers but very soft and sensual. Dark Amber is pretty much the most beautiful amber fragrance I've had under my nose and, above all, it retains its boundless beauty, whereas Amber Star, one of Xerjoff's most popular amber fragrances, eventually develops a very unpleasant sweetness. I have a comparison, but I won't go into it here. The bottle is generally rated a 7.4. If you consider that the bottle of Le Male by Gaultier is rated with a 7.7, you should realize that the value of the Dark Amber bottle is absolutely absurd and in no way reflects reality and no, I am not a Birkholz fanboy, if then from Xerjoff. The longevity is absolutely outstanding and the sillage is very good by amber standards. The fragrance comes with a perfect amber-vanilla-tonka bean combination, the sweet seductive scent makes me dream over and over again. I have never smelled anything like it before and I have really spent a lot of money on testers from many well-known manufacturers in the last six months.
0 Comments
5
Pricing
7
Bottle
8
Sillage
8
Longevity
9
Scent
Luca1202

4 Reviews
Translated Show original Show translation
Luca1202
Luca1202
1  
Hmmm Delicious
For me, it is a wonderful fragrance First and foremost, for me it is beautifully sweet, vanilla creamy and yet it has something dark but only very gentle in combination with a slight spiciness, which makes it very pleasant and not too intrusive for me. I would say that the fragrance is a very nice creation for the colder season, only the price is a bit over the top in my eyes.
0 Comments
7
Pricing
7
Bottle
7
Sillage
7
Longevity
7.5
Scent
PDeen

5 Reviews
Translated Show original Show translation
PDeen
PDeen
0  
Dark feel-good aura
A beautiful gourmand that is given a slightly fresh touch by the lime and green notes. Pepper is a very subliminal companion that gives the fragrance its zest. The fragrance also has something slightly wicked about it. It's therefore also a good fragrance for exciting date nights ;)
I can definitely see it in the evening in both classic and rock style. In my opinion, it goes very well with a jazz lounge, for example, where you sit together in the evening in charming company and enjoy the atmosphere.
0 Comments
More reviews

Statements

2 short views on the fragrance
MyrtillajusMyrtillajus 10 months ago
Dark Amber is a deep, sensual, enveloping fragrance
0 Comments
HermeshHermesh 4 years ago
8
Bottle
8
Sillage
8
Longevity
6.5
Scent
Ambery creamy sandalwood with indefinable floral-fruity sweetness and a scratchy, synthetic note. Rather nonspectacular.
0 Comments

Charts

This is how the community classifies the fragrance.
Pie Chart Radar Chart

Images

2 fragrance photos of the community

Popular by Vintner's Reserve

Mulled Wine by Vintner's Reserve Draught of Living Death by Vintner's Reserve Potion for Dreamless Sleep by Vintner's Reserve Amortentia by Vintner's Reserve Banana Pudding by Vintner's Reserve Spiked Egg Nog by Vintner's Reserve Mexican Hot Chocolate by Vintner's Reserve Candy Cane Martini by Vintner's Reserve Mary Pickford by Vintner's Reserve Sidecar by Vintner's Reserve Monkey Gland by Vintner's Reserve Bee's Knees by Vintner's Reserve Old Fashioned by Vintner's Reserve Come Together by Vintner's Reserve Witch, Please by Vintner's Reserve Hot Toddy by Vintner's Reserve Blackberry Mojito by Vintner's Reserve Pina Colada by Vintner's Reserve Sex on the Beach by Vintner's Reserve Strawberry Daiquiri by Vintner's Reserve Port Wine Truffle by Vintner's Reserve