
NicheOnly
149 Reviews

NicheOnly
3
Nuance & complexity, but not necessarily depth
Moving into the latter half of my Folkwinds coverage, I still have the heavy hitters coming and one of those is Crimson and Clover. While the fragrance features significant strengths, I find myself dwelling over the fact that Crimson and Clover is yet another Folkwinds fragrance that doesn't put enough emphasis on the wearable aspects of perfumery.
Having gone through the evolution twice, I'd argue the opening of Crimson and Clover is the clear highlight of the profile: much like some of the previous Folkwinds I've reviewed, I notice a medicinal amber, but in Crimson & Clover, that amber is opposed by a significant dose of apple tobacco and moderate-to-strong animalic nuances. In the niche realm, this structure is somewhat similar to the idea of combining the apple shisha smell of Kilian's Smoking Hot and the amber tobacco smell of Xerjoff's Empiryan. Obviously indie quality is present and there is depth beyond what this hypothetical combination has to offer, esp. as I suspect there is some oud utilized in the base, but the idea that this is an indie-quality and high-depth alternative to products like Smoking Hot and Tobacolor definitely isn't among the most outrageous statements I've made in a review.
Trying to match the experience to the structure, the scent features strong touches from the apple cider and apple notes listed in the top & bottom. These apple notes are accentuated well by an added sweet note, whether that be the ginger, the clover, the honey or some mix of the aforementioned. The tobacco, listed as green tobacco, doesn't smell like a niche tobacco: it has a very specific aromatic-leafy smell to it that has touches of tea, meaning the primary accords for this scent, esp. in the dry-down, are clearly going to be spicy-woody. I also smell some mix of the castoreum and Vietnamese oud offering up both animalic & smoky touches, but I find these parts more relevant in the top than in the base where the tobacco stars as the main character and I'd argue the dry-down doesn't actually feature a lot of depth beyond either just the tobacco or the mix of tobacco and aromatic notes.
Unlike the other Folkwinds I've sampled so far, I find the performance of Crimson and Clover somewhat conservative. I am going to put longevity between 8 and 10 hours, but the sillage really varies by how long you've had the scent on. I'd say the opening sillage is moderate-to-strong (between a 6 and 7/10), but it gradually (and rather quickly) degrades into something that will occasionally waft in arm's length (between a 3 and 4/10), so I'm going to balance the two and put it in the middle at a 5/10. At the time of review, Crimson and Clover sold out at a $495/50ml price point where I'd argue it's average value. As indicated in the opening chapter, I feel like I would've rated it higher if it successfully built around the apple better, but as is the case in most indie fragrances, the hefty usage of complex materials leads to reduced dimensionality while putting focus on the idea of smelling "aggressively different".
Having gone through the evolution twice, I'd argue the opening of Crimson and Clover is the clear highlight of the profile: much like some of the previous Folkwinds I've reviewed, I notice a medicinal amber, but in Crimson & Clover, that amber is opposed by a significant dose of apple tobacco and moderate-to-strong animalic nuances. In the niche realm, this structure is somewhat similar to the idea of combining the apple shisha smell of Kilian's Smoking Hot and the amber tobacco smell of Xerjoff's Empiryan. Obviously indie quality is present and there is depth beyond what this hypothetical combination has to offer, esp. as I suspect there is some oud utilized in the base, but the idea that this is an indie-quality and high-depth alternative to products like Smoking Hot and Tobacolor definitely isn't among the most outrageous statements I've made in a review.
Trying to match the experience to the structure, the scent features strong touches from the apple cider and apple notes listed in the top & bottom. These apple notes are accentuated well by an added sweet note, whether that be the ginger, the clover, the honey or some mix of the aforementioned. The tobacco, listed as green tobacco, doesn't smell like a niche tobacco: it has a very specific aromatic-leafy smell to it that has touches of tea, meaning the primary accords for this scent, esp. in the dry-down, are clearly going to be spicy-woody. I also smell some mix of the castoreum and Vietnamese oud offering up both animalic & smoky touches, but I find these parts more relevant in the top than in the base where the tobacco stars as the main character and I'd argue the dry-down doesn't actually feature a lot of depth beyond either just the tobacco or the mix of tobacco and aromatic notes.
Unlike the other Folkwinds I've sampled so far, I find the performance of Crimson and Clover somewhat conservative. I am going to put longevity between 8 and 10 hours, but the sillage really varies by how long you've had the scent on. I'd say the opening sillage is moderate-to-strong (between a 6 and 7/10), but it gradually (and rather quickly) degrades into something that will occasionally waft in arm's length (between a 3 and 4/10), so I'm going to balance the two and put it in the middle at a 5/10. At the time of review, Crimson and Clover sold out at a $495/50ml price point where I'd argue it's average value. As indicated in the opening chapter, I feel like I would've rated it higher if it successfully built around the apple better, but as is the case in most indie fragrances, the hefty usage of complex materials leads to reduced dimensionality while putting focus on the idea of smelling "aggressively different".
Updated on 01/29/2026



Cranberry
Apple cider
Poplar
Clove
Ginger
Green tobacco
Hay
Sweet clover
Thai oud
Cassia
Vetiver
Apple
Amber
American oak
American Rosa rugosa
Castoreum
Cigar
Orris root
Red spruce
Santalol
Vermont honey
Vermont sugar maple
Barley malt
Deertongue
Grass
Mongolian musk
Sugar maple







BertolucciK
djoc192
Antro
NicheOnly
andrelouis































