Lieselotte
La chair est faible
2 years ago - 09/02/2023
9 5
When is a fragrance collection great?

When is a fragrance collection great?

I've never been one to aim for greatness in my hobbies, doing my very best and making sure I enjoy the process has proved to often be good enough to justify how I spend my leisure time and resources. Thus in my approach to collecting fragrances, I have done the same- set my objectives for what I ultimately want, and rules to guide my decisions in accumulating what is (let's be honest with ourselves) a luxury, not a need.

Lately I've seen quite a lot of rants/ spilling the tea/ bursting the bubble/ exposing the dark side YouTube videos and fragrance blogs, all bewailing what to me is a rather simple problem. Like one examines loose fruit in the supermarket before making a choice, I would like for you to consider an aspect of the problem being discussed on several platforms, with me- the need or perhaps better put, the pursuit of a 'great' fragrance collection. Dear reader, what to you, makes a fragrance collection great?

If you had asked me this question two years ago, influenced by a form of flex culture in collecting, my answer would have been naïve at best. I'd have retorted, "A great collection is one that houses discontinued/ vintage/ first edition perfumes, or a large catalogue of niche, designer and affordable fragrances. Perhaps even a collection that could serve as a museum of sorts." Now, my answer would not have been wrong, only biased. Was greatness then something that could only be achieved by those advanced in years in the hobby or who had spent a lifetime amassing weird and wonderful fragrances?

Shall we move on to a year ago and examine what my answer would've been? Influenced by the many tempting videos on YouTube and being in possession of over 50 bottles of fragrances, my answer would've been along the lines of greatness is directly proportionate to the number of varied bottles you own.

Again, let's take a step back into time, will 6 months ago suffice? I was living a nomadic lifestyle of sorts, having ported a few full bottles of fragrance with me for my months of rootlessness in travel. In that period of life, I would've insisted that a great collection is one where you are intimately aware of every single bottle of scent in your collection. One you can discuss their behaviours in all seasons, one so carefully curated that you could not bear to part with any.

And here we are in September 2023 and I think I finally have an answer that I am satisfied with. Before you read it, could you tell me in the comments section what your definition of a great collection is, at this point in your life and collecting journey?

Alas, we reach the end of my ponderings. Can we agree to disagree and laugh about how different people approach life in different ways? And will you understand me if I say that a collection is only great when you, the collector, says it's great. And until you do, 'greatness' will always be that milestone 'just ahead' that you never quite seem to reach.

Last updated 09/03/2023 - 11:44 AM
9 Comments
ChillScentChillScent 2 years ago
1
I thought that there are many kinds of collectors. The "great" will come along with the taste and knowledge of the collectors. It's not only about the quantity, It's also the quality/memory that really means to the collectors and somehow the great definition is not for all.
Collecting is a journey, and it's great when you found that collections satisfy your frag-feeling.
Time changes, thing changes, also the collections...
Exciter76Exciter76 2 years ago
1
Fantastic article! 👏🏾👏🏾👏🏾
When I first began my fragrance journey online—because, prior to that, I was an avid collector of perfumes, just not a very savvy one—I compared myself to other collectors. I thought a good collection was the one I attempted to copy from a collector on the other side of the world who had thousands of bottles of vintage, designer, niche, limited edition, you name it. It took many years and just enough debt to learn the best collection FOR ME was the one that made ME happy.
JoeTraudlJoeTraudl 2 years ago
1
What great food for thought to raise one's awareness of the multitude of variation in this wonderful world of fragrance. Your comments about various aspects of your individual life stages and the accompanying change in one's own personal definition of a great collection, definitely make me wonder about superficialities of a collection, especially as a newcomer to the scene. I want to collect with heart and fall in love with my collection.
Thank you for this suggestion!
LempiLempi 2 years ago
2
Such an interesting article! My reply to the question is very personal, but in my opinion my collection is great when it brings me joy and makes me happy. That's the purpose of fragrances for me. 🥰
TzapanTzapan 2 years ago
2
I could never say such a statement (my collection is great and fulfilled) simply because i have no clue of what a great collection of fragrances is like. I do own some vintage now disrupted scents just because of respect and love towards this at of perfumery ,the 22 or 23 notes so well blended and rounded none is prominent but all serve a masterpiece. I seek the humble many times and essential. A fragrance is not always bount to be a goldie best seller. I seek for the undiscovered gems often.
KuraiKurai 2 years ago
2
I think a collection is great when it comes with a story. I don't mean some lame facts about OG formulations or how rare the ingredients are. No, personal anecdotes and unforgettable experiences, that's what makes a collection great. From that perspective, unfortunately, my collection is far from great xD
RingtaleRingtale 2 years ago
1
Actually I feel as though my collection will be great if I have found one or two, maybe three perfumes that will make me feel good and will satisfy my olfactory taste completely. Then I would bring my less favourite perfumes to a second hand shop and I will be left with just those few perfumes. It would be such a relief not to have so much trouble picking a perfume for the day or night. Yes. I think I'd be satisfied with a collection of no more than three 'signature' perfumes actually....
On the other hand...it is so much fun to know about many perfumes and to be able to share it with others... :-)
OmnipotatoOmnipotato 2 years ago
2
I think a great collection is one that is your own, i.e. to your own taste. I've seen so many that are just collections of fragrances that YouTubers, influencers, reviewers think are good, and it seems to me the collector is desperately trying to smell "good" according to some objective ideal that obviously doesn't exist. I definitely agree with you that a good collection should be varied in terms of scent profile, perfumer, and brand, but it should also reflect your personal vibe and taste.
TelekinecTelekinec 2 years ago
1
I think the collection is great if the collector is satisfied of his collection and if the perfumes are shown to have some dents. I don't care for the number - it can be small or big- but I'm hoping the person has a few memories associated to a few perfumes. For example, my Thé Yulong is starting to have a dent and I have a memory associated to it (discovering a great tea perfume / trip to NY with my boyfriend), but I'm not yet satisfied with my collection. I'm still discovering what I like, I have perfumes I'm starting to outgrow, etc.
By money standard (for a a person with an average mean of living) I have quite the collection (20 bottles), by snobs I only have influencer-curated and Sephora addicted perfumes, but for me, it's a collection that shows my journey, how I struggled at first to determine what I liked, what I discovered by surprise, what I got from other people's opinion. It's not perfect yet, but it doesn tell the story of my journey into this hobby!

More articles by Lieselotte