At odds with the community, which perceives it as smoky, I was also torn here and ultimately wanted to know for myself. In my opinion - at this point, Amouage fans should look away - the highly praised
Interlude Man and "Interlude Black Iris | Amouage," which are compared to this scent here, have nothing smoky about them and are identical for me, except for the opening, and quite sweet as well. For all three fragrances acting here, the community's perception is currently primarily smoky-spicy.
And I must admit that Eterno and Interlude resemble each other at first sniff to a level that scares me. Yet there is still nothing smoky about it. Sorry.
Interlude Man against Eterno. Here, almost 1400 reviews face less than 30. Is that fair? The ratings are at least similar enough to justify a comparison. And yet I want one thing above all: that I like this one better. We shall see.
Away from the comparison, let's focus on Eterno.
The opening is excitingly fresh, full of lime, which I usually don't notice at all, probably because it's intensified by the spice of the lemon leaf. However, the slight shower gel vibes cannot be ignored.
The vibes diminish, while soft flowers clear the background for increasingly louder resins and old leather.
The various resins appear fiery on a green, floral base.
Special twist
It is indeed a pleasure to sniff this interpretation of these ingredients. Because despite the exciting and rather heavy resins, without perceiving incense and smoke, there remains enough dynamism in the composition to avoid being overwhelming. It is therefore not a typical resin scent, which most perceive as suitable for cold days and otherwise not fitting, but is light and long-lasting enough to also make a good impression on warm days without being overpowering. On the contrary. It is precisely the balsamic and soft notes that stand out now.
I am thrilled!