Kol
Reviews
Kol
Scents and Sensibility: An Evaluation of the Y
Recently, a friend of mine gave me his leftover. This gesture, I chose to interpret as an invitation to write a review.
Bottle:
Better than the average designer type bottle. Fancy gradient glass with the metal Y. Simple and elegant, yet has details where it counts. I do especially like the cut-in bit in between the branches of the Y. The cap weights a little over 25 grams and it is plasticy and it's loose on my example. I have certainly seen better caps. Both the Y and the top of the cap are brushed aluminium, but the collar of the atomizer is chromed and it's somewhat upsetting. The atomizer has a solid, well weighted feel, that maybe loses some sturdiness at the end of the press.
Scent:
The fragrance greets you with an assertive blend of sage, apple, and ginger, complemented by a subtle whisper of bergamot. The mixture of these elements is distinctly pleasing, and carries the stamp of a well-crafted designer ethos. Simple and elegant. Noticing a theme here. After the initial havoc of these above mention aggressive notes clam down. Past the dry-down, we get to meet some geranium and a variety of base notes, which at this point are hard to tell apart. Concurrently, the sage begins a delicate dance with the juniper berry, turns into a softer, more emotional accord. At this point some might think that we are discussing the scent profile of an avant garde Head & Shoulders shampoo, but the fragrance is saved from such a comparisons by a well-balanced blend of sweet base notes. These include amberwood, frankincense and tonka bean blended so seamlessly that it becomes challenging to identify either one them. Nonetheless, the blend does not have the balmy quality often associated with these elements. A hour later, the scent is losing integrity, unfortunately, and unfolds into a less complex version of its former self. A hint of balsamic quality emerges, lending warmth to the remaining traces of sage and juniper berry.
Performance:
A tendency with the designer fragrance is scalability. As if by design it's impossible to use too much of it. Strikingly, irrespective of whether you spray 2 or 10, neither the sillage(as in distance) nor the longevity intensifies. Rather, the scent's potency within the sillage area is amplified, but less and less with every additional spray. This might sound like some abstract conspiracy theory, but the previous owner of this particular Y fragrance has sprayed no fewer than 10 times, yet the scent wasn't noticeably more potent or pervasive compared to my restrained application of two sprays.
Anyways, the performance is above average, it's a solid "good". A recommended, 4 sprays will accompany you for a span of 6+ hours. Keep keep in mind that the power drops a good 30% after the first hour.
Use Case:
The Y is a good all-rounder. It's versatile enough for you to wear it just about anywhere, whether you're at work or out with friends. The only time it might not hit hard enough is during the colder winter months, as its scent isn't as strong and warming as some of the heavier winter fragrances out there. For big events, especially those in the evening, you might want to pick something with a bit more punch. While the Y is a nice enough scent, those special occasions are a great opportunity to wear something a bit more unique and memorable.
Kol score:
6.9/10 - Not a bad frag, but as others pointed out it's just "Ok".
Bottle:
Better than the average designer type bottle. Fancy gradient glass with the metal Y. Simple and elegant, yet has details where it counts. I do especially like the cut-in bit in between the branches of the Y. The cap weights a little over 25 grams and it is plasticy and it's loose on my example. I have certainly seen better caps. Both the Y and the top of the cap are brushed aluminium, but the collar of the atomizer is chromed and it's somewhat upsetting. The atomizer has a solid, well weighted feel, that maybe loses some sturdiness at the end of the press.
Scent:
The fragrance greets you with an assertive blend of sage, apple, and ginger, complemented by a subtle whisper of bergamot. The mixture of these elements is distinctly pleasing, and carries the stamp of a well-crafted designer ethos. Simple and elegant. Noticing a theme here. After the initial havoc of these above mention aggressive notes clam down. Past the dry-down, we get to meet some geranium and a variety of base notes, which at this point are hard to tell apart. Concurrently, the sage begins a delicate dance with the juniper berry, turns into a softer, more emotional accord. At this point some might think that we are discussing the scent profile of an avant garde Head & Shoulders shampoo, but the fragrance is saved from such a comparisons by a well-balanced blend of sweet base notes. These include amberwood, frankincense and tonka bean blended so seamlessly that it becomes challenging to identify either one them. Nonetheless, the blend does not have the balmy quality often associated with these elements. A hour later, the scent is losing integrity, unfortunately, and unfolds into a less complex version of its former self. A hint of balsamic quality emerges, lending warmth to the remaining traces of sage and juniper berry.
Performance:
A tendency with the designer fragrance is scalability. As if by design it's impossible to use too much of it. Strikingly, irrespective of whether you spray 2 or 10, neither the sillage(as in distance) nor the longevity intensifies. Rather, the scent's potency within the sillage area is amplified, but less and less with every additional spray. This might sound like some abstract conspiracy theory, but the previous owner of this particular Y fragrance has sprayed no fewer than 10 times, yet the scent wasn't noticeably more potent or pervasive compared to my restrained application of two sprays.
Anyways, the performance is above average, it's a solid "good". A recommended, 4 sprays will accompany you for a span of 6+ hours. Keep keep in mind that the power drops a good 30% after the first hour.
Use Case:
The Y is a good all-rounder. It's versatile enough for you to wear it just about anywhere, whether you're at work or out with friends. The only time it might not hit hard enough is during the colder winter months, as its scent isn't as strong and warming as some of the heavier winter fragrances out there. For big events, especially those in the evening, you might want to pick something with a bit more punch. While the Y is a nice enough scent, those special occasions are a great opportunity to wear something a bit more unique and memorable.
Kol score:
6.9/10 - Not a bad frag, but as others pointed out it's just "Ok".
Whispers of Leather and Enigmatic Sweetness
I'd heard some really good things about this perfume, so I decided to head to Zara to pick it up. After spending a few minutes searching the perfume section, I was told that it was sold out. Apparently, it was such a hit that it was gone from most stores. But there was still hope - I was informed that a store about half an hour away might have a bottle left.
So, off I went. After a bit of a drive, I finally arrived at the other store. Turns out they did have the last bottle, but it wasn't even out on the shelves. Some guy had to go fetch it from the back. He looked a bit angry, probably because he had wanted it for himself.
Bottle:
I usually don't have high expectations for fragrances that cost 20 euros, but to be honest, Zara managed to underwhelmed me with the tilted text on the bottle. Otherwise, it gets the job done. The atomizer lets you half-spray it, which I usually like and especially appreciate with a fragrance that has become my choice for "unimportant night-out" situations.
Scent:
It opens with a very strong and relatively nice iris note, which is just a little too powdery, but well accompanied by a leathery note. The leathery note brings to mind chrome-tanned leather sneakers. The combination of iris and leather is nothing new, but it works well this time too.
So far, so good. One would think it's great, even after noticing the citrus accord hiding behind the iris. The combination is vibrant, yet maybe a little soapy at times. But then the sweetness kicks in—an extremely strong, unnatural type of sweetness. It's the kind of sweetness that a bug-eating plant would emit to lure in, confuse, and ultimately make its prey surrender. The sweetness is almost sickening and absolutely soulless. Don't get me wrong, I don't hate it. I just can't really place it in my head. It's somewhat gourmandy, but not tonka bean; it's something synthetic. The scent is rather linear and doesn't change much over time. If anything, the leather and sweetness remain the most dominant notes.
Comparison:
In our olfactory lineup, we have three rivals.
J.P.G. Ultra Male:
As anticipated, Ultra Male is better. However, personally, I prefer this Zara budget beast over it.
Afnan 9pm:
It should be a fair comparison, given how both 9pm and G.L. are considered Ultra Male homages and the prices are similar, but I really, really disliked 9pm and do like the Zara fragrance.
And lastly, Valentino Uomo Intense (new version):
I have noticed similarities when sniffing this Valentino fragrance, which is no wonder because the formula is also similar on paper. However, Valentino is a lot more refined and complex.
Performance:
It's strong enough. People will notice it. I'd say it has a 1-meter sillage for the first 3-4 hours, half a meter for the next 2 hours, ultimately demanding a rather intimate proximity for the final 2 hours.
Use Case:
This fragrance seems to resonate with warmer climates, but it feels somewhat discordant in the winter's chill. It might be overbearing in the peak of summer. So, spring or autumn evenings could be the perfect stage for this scent, especially for an al fresco dinner with friends or a dance party.
Kol Score:
7/10
So, off I went. After a bit of a drive, I finally arrived at the other store. Turns out they did have the last bottle, but it wasn't even out on the shelves. Some guy had to go fetch it from the back. He looked a bit angry, probably because he had wanted it for himself.
Bottle:
I usually don't have high expectations for fragrances that cost 20 euros, but to be honest, Zara managed to underwhelmed me with the tilted text on the bottle. Otherwise, it gets the job done. The atomizer lets you half-spray it, which I usually like and especially appreciate with a fragrance that has become my choice for "unimportant night-out" situations.
Scent:
It opens with a very strong and relatively nice iris note, which is just a little too powdery, but well accompanied by a leathery note. The leathery note brings to mind chrome-tanned leather sneakers. The combination of iris and leather is nothing new, but it works well this time too.
So far, so good. One would think it's great, even after noticing the citrus accord hiding behind the iris. The combination is vibrant, yet maybe a little soapy at times. But then the sweetness kicks in—an extremely strong, unnatural type of sweetness. It's the kind of sweetness that a bug-eating plant would emit to lure in, confuse, and ultimately make its prey surrender. The sweetness is almost sickening and absolutely soulless. Don't get me wrong, I don't hate it. I just can't really place it in my head. It's somewhat gourmandy, but not tonka bean; it's something synthetic. The scent is rather linear and doesn't change much over time. If anything, the leather and sweetness remain the most dominant notes.
Comparison:
In our olfactory lineup, we have three rivals.
J.P.G. Ultra Male:
As anticipated, Ultra Male is better. However, personally, I prefer this Zara budget beast over it.
Afnan 9pm:
It should be a fair comparison, given how both 9pm and G.L. are considered Ultra Male homages and the prices are similar, but I really, really disliked 9pm and do like the Zara fragrance.
And lastly, Valentino Uomo Intense (new version):
I have noticed similarities when sniffing this Valentino fragrance, which is no wonder because the formula is also similar on paper. However, Valentino is a lot more refined and complex.
Performance:
It's strong enough. People will notice it. I'd say it has a 1-meter sillage for the first 3-4 hours, half a meter for the next 2 hours, ultimately demanding a rather intimate proximity for the final 2 hours.
Use Case:
This fragrance seems to resonate with warmer climates, but it feels somewhat discordant in the winter's chill. It might be overbearing in the peak of summer. So, spring or autumn evenings could be the perfect stage for this scent, especially for an al fresco dinner with friends or a dance party.
Kol Score:
7/10
2 Comments
Encre Noire Sport: Fresh and Sophisticated
I'm absolutely in love with it!
The scent is very sophisticated, masculine and invigorating, yet also light and refreshing. It has a woody and smoky base, same as the EN which is said to "smell like a graveyard, but in a good way", that is complemented by a hint of citrus(grapefruit sweetened by bergamot) and lavender. The whole idea of "black ink with sporty-fresh touches" really fits the scent profile. I need to add that it's somewhat synthetic and soulless - but that was expected.
It is a great everyday scent that is perfect for casual or even formal occasions. Won't get in the way nor offend anybody. The sillage power is impressive too, but the longevity is average. I can still smell it 4 hours after I've applied it, but will quickly lose projection after the 4 hour mark.
Highly recommended for anyone looking for an enjoyable, unique, fresh... and unapologetic cheap fragrance.
Ps.: I have experienced the normal Encre Noire and I prefer the sport.
The scent is very sophisticated, masculine and invigorating, yet also light and refreshing. It has a woody and smoky base, same as the EN which is said to "smell like a graveyard, but in a good way", that is complemented by a hint of citrus(grapefruit sweetened by bergamot) and lavender. The whole idea of "black ink with sporty-fresh touches" really fits the scent profile. I need to add that it's somewhat synthetic and soulless - but that was expected.
It is a great everyday scent that is perfect for casual or even formal occasions. Won't get in the way nor offend anybody. The sillage power is impressive too, but the longevity is average. I can still smell it 4 hours after I've applied it, but will quickly lose projection after the 4 hour mark.
Highly recommended for anyone looking for an enjoyable, unique, fresh... and unapologetic cheap fragrance.
Ps.: I have experienced the normal Encre Noire and I prefer the sport.
A Fresh and Manly Scent for All Occasions
I recently purchased the Armaf Club De Nuit (pure parfum) and I have to say, it is an amazing scent for the price.
The top notes are all there; lemon, black currant, apple, bergamot, pineapple... You'll get to meet each of these at some point after spraying it. The PP concentration is quite okay when it comes to the infamous "toxic" opening. However, it does kinda remind me of a certain industrial marble floor care liquid that my father's cleaning company used to use. Personally, I don't necessarily dislike it, but make sure to don't go near anyone 10 minutes after spraying it on.
The middle notes provide a floral accords, converting the scent to something that's enjoyable. The base notes are well balanced and a much need warmth making the scent inviting.
The bottle is just okay. My PP concentration comes in 150ml which is not easy to hold and aim properly, especially with the inaccurate atomizer.
It is a strong, long-lasting fragrance that has great sillage and can be worn day or night. It is a great scent for any occasion and I would highly recommend it to anyone looking for a fresh and manly scent that's good for most occasions.
The top notes are all there; lemon, black currant, apple, bergamot, pineapple... You'll get to meet each of these at some point after spraying it. The PP concentration is quite okay when it comes to the infamous "toxic" opening. However, it does kinda remind me of a certain industrial marble floor care liquid that my father's cleaning company used to use. Personally, I don't necessarily dislike it, but make sure to don't go near anyone 10 minutes after spraying it on.
The middle notes provide a floral accords, converting the scent to something that's enjoyable. The base notes are well balanced and a much need warmth making the scent inviting.
The bottle is just okay. My PP concentration comes in 150ml which is not easy to hold and aim properly, especially with the inaccurate atomizer.
It is a strong, long-lasting fragrance that has great sillage and can be worn day or night. It is a great scent for any occasion and I would highly recommend it to anyone looking for a fresh and manly scent that's good for most occasions.
Aromatic Greek Forest Experience
Molecule 05 emits a unique and captivating aroma of earth, warmth, herbs, and citrus that brings to mind a forest in Greece on a hot summer day. It opens with a woody, masculine, and dark scent, transitioning to a gentle and sweet citrus-floral scent. It's absolutely unisex. Performance is so-so.
I'd say, this fragrance is perfect for anyone looking for an aromatic, green, and earthy experience... that's a little different.
I'd say, this fragrance is perfect for anyone looking for an aromatic, green, and earthy experience... that's a little different.
