09/23/2024

Smirky
450 Reviews

Smirky
Very helpful Review
3
Very nice Hacivat flanker
This is a combined review of Hacivat and Hacivat X which I tested from samples on consecutive days and also compared directly. I've never tried Adventus, so can't compare these to it. I do have and enjoy Montblanc Explorer.
Hacivat is a really nice, strong and masculine fragrance with a great pineapple-citrusy opening. The dry down does have some subtle old school vibes with the oak moss and woody accord. Hacivat strikes me as much smoother and less woody than Hacivat X and Explorer. Overall scent is people pleasing and is a definite versatile easy grab for most any occasion. Longevity is very good with strong sillage.
On to Hacivat X. The major different between it and the OG is that X has a much more pronounced woody accord, the pineapple/citrusy opening is not as prominent and X comes across as sharper or less smooth. The OG seems a bit sweeter than X. I'd also say that Hacivat X is closer to Explorer, although Explorer is even sharper and more woody. X is also a very masculine fragrance (perhaps more so than the OG) with the same great performance as the OG.
In the final analysis, Hacivat and Hacivat X are both great fragrances, so it just comes down to personal choice on which you'd prefer. My preference leans towards the OG and it isn't redundant seeing that I also have Explorer (they don't smell alike). Hacivat X would be redundant since it's much closer to Explorer. My recommendation would be to start with Hacivat. If you want something woodier, go with Hacivat X.
Hacivat is a really nice, strong and masculine fragrance with a great pineapple-citrusy opening. The dry down does have some subtle old school vibes with the oak moss and woody accord. Hacivat strikes me as much smoother and less woody than Hacivat X and Explorer. Overall scent is people pleasing and is a definite versatile easy grab for most any occasion. Longevity is very good with strong sillage.
On to Hacivat X. The major different between it and the OG is that X has a much more pronounced woody accord, the pineapple/citrusy opening is not as prominent and X comes across as sharper or less smooth. The OG seems a bit sweeter than X. I'd also say that Hacivat X is closer to Explorer, although Explorer is even sharper and more woody. X is also a very masculine fragrance (perhaps more so than the OG) with the same great performance as the OG.
In the final analysis, Hacivat and Hacivat X are both great fragrances, so it just comes down to personal choice on which you'd prefer. My preference leans towards the OG and it isn't redundant seeing that I also have Explorer (they don't smell alike). Hacivat X would be redundant since it's much closer to Explorer. My recommendation would be to start with Hacivat. If you want something woodier, go with Hacivat X.