
sushipgh
2 Reviews

sushipgh
2
More Herod than Herod
As this was the first scent I received unsolicited compliments on, it will be my first review here as well.
As part of my newfound interest in fragrances, I had gotten a Herod decant and found I was intrigued by the sophisticated blend of scents in it: not quite flowery, not quite sugary, and very little tobacco presence compared to every other tobacco perfumes I have. But this feels like it's made by Houdini or something - it's an escape artist. I get a couple minutes of projection, then like 15 minutes of a close skin scent, and then after that it's only a hint you can pick up if you literally put your nose on my skin.
So I wanted to see what else could give me this, without it absconding with all this lovely scent. Based on the reviews I blind bought this Hercules. I was wearing it last night at a yoga class when two women noticed it, and when I invited them to get a closer sniff of it, their eyes lit up in delight. So clearly it projects better than its inspiration does.
As I type this, I have Hercules on one wrist, and Herod on the other. I'm trying to summarize this before the Herod sneaks off again.
Hercules definitely opens with a much boozier alcohol note than Herod does. Herod only gives a few moments of a clean alcohol smell and then settles down. The Hercules keeps that booziness for more like 5-8 minutes.
There's a sheen of oils on the Hercules side and its scent volume feels about double what the Herod is projecting. So this opening is the biggest difference between the two. Once past that, as the Herod is fading, the Hercules is still quite present, but they are clearly close siblings of one another. The Herod definitely is the more plush, powdery, and balanced of the two. Hercules isn't one dimensional, but it brings more spice in the front, or at least it's louder, and more smoky wood and incense behind it.
As we slide towards drydown, the Herod has gone into hiding. I don't know if it's my skin, but others have commented similarly, so it's not my imagination. It's a delicious little hint of a scent, but oh so quiet. I think this is a scent more for the wearer than anyone else. It still makes me smile, but I have no way to share it with anyone.
Hercules, however, despite whatever labours the gods had him busy with, is still a trooper. Slightly diminished, but still discernable from a distance. The spiciness mellows somewhat, still peppery, less vanilla, but the musk creeps in, and the mild wood and tobacco notes finally show up, lingering behind this.
I also have Tobacco Noir , another clone in the same DNA. It's a different beast. A bit darker, more frankincense bordering on a patchouli, shows up in that one. Hercules stays a bit sweeter, perhaps more of an evening fragrance than the late night shenanigans of the TN.
So my final takeaway: Hercules isn't quite Herod. It's not a 1:1. But if Herod is going to be uselessly unwearable for me, Hercules makes a bigger statement, and still brings a smile to my face, and apparently also to those around me who notice it. The confident, warm masculine presence it offers is definitely going to be in my rotation.
As part of my newfound interest in fragrances, I had gotten a Herod decant and found I was intrigued by the sophisticated blend of scents in it: not quite flowery, not quite sugary, and very little tobacco presence compared to every other tobacco perfumes I have. But this feels like it's made by Houdini or something - it's an escape artist. I get a couple minutes of projection, then like 15 minutes of a close skin scent, and then after that it's only a hint you can pick up if you literally put your nose on my skin.
So I wanted to see what else could give me this, without it absconding with all this lovely scent. Based on the reviews I blind bought this Hercules. I was wearing it last night at a yoga class when two women noticed it, and when I invited them to get a closer sniff of it, their eyes lit up in delight. So clearly it projects better than its inspiration does.
As I type this, I have Hercules on one wrist, and Herod on the other. I'm trying to summarize this before the Herod sneaks off again.
Hercules definitely opens with a much boozier alcohol note than Herod does. Herod only gives a few moments of a clean alcohol smell and then settles down. The Hercules keeps that booziness for more like 5-8 minutes.
There's a sheen of oils on the Hercules side and its scent volume feels about double what the Herod is projecting. So this opening is the biggest difference between the two. Once past that, as the Herod is fading, the Hercules is still quite present, but they are clearly close siblings of one another. The Herod definitely is the more plush, powdery, and balanced of the two. Hercules isn't one dimensional, but it brings more spice in the front, or at least it's louder, and more smoky wood and incense behind it.
As we slide towards drydown, the Herod has gone into hiding. I don't know if it's my skin, but others have commented similarly, so it's not my imagination. It's a delicious little hint of a scent, but oh so quiet. I think this is a scent more for the wearer than anyone else. It still makes me smile, but I have no way to share it with anyone.
Hercules, however, despite whatever labours the gods had him busy with, is still a trooper. Slightly diminished, but still discernable from a distance. The spiciness mellows somewhat, still peppery, less vanilla, but the musk creeps in, and the mild wood and tobacco notes finally show up, lingering behind this.
I also have Tobacco Noir , another clone in the same DNA. It's a different beast. A bit darker, more frankincense bordering on a patchouli, shows up in that one. Hercules stays a bit sweeter, perhaps more of an evening fragrance than the late night shenanigans of the TN.
So my final takeaway: Hercules isn't quite Herod. It's not a 1:1. But if Herod is going to be uselessly unwearable for me, Hercules makes a bigger statement, and still brings a smile to my face, and apparently also to those around me who notice it. The confident, warm masculine presence it offers is definitely going to be in my rotation.
Updated on 11/04/2026



Cinnamon
Pepper
Tobacco
Osmanthus
Frankincense
Labdanum
Musk
Vanilla
Nagarmotha
Cedarwood
Vetiver








AdelFfm
Flyview
dwrestle
malmeidav
Newtype777







































