05/27/2020

Rosie88
Translated
Show original

Rosie88
Top Review
29
1:1 comparison of EDT and EDP
Although the story of Coco Chanel, or rather Gabrielle Chasnel is really very interesting and remarkable, the Chanel scents have never really appealed to me...
"Chanel is cult, must have" - "Chanel is modern, and must have" - "Chanel is famous, must have" --- No, you don't... ;-)
Nevertheless, it happened recently that a very nice person brought Bois des Îles ("BdI") to my attention and gave me the opportunity to test and compare the EDP and the EDT (of which the production was unfortunately discontinued). Many thanks at this point :)
After I have tested both versions extensively, I would like to tell you about my 1:1 comparison:
Left the EDT and right the EDP.
The EDT starts bright, citric-fruity and with delicate and soft-sweet ylang flowers
Strong, but not pushy. slightly "soapy" but not "old-fashioned"...
... little by little creamy-sweet wood sounds join in, soft and yet "palpable"... the fragrance becomes wonderfully creamy, like a 2nd skin... close to the body, but still always there... a tender aura spreads, wonderful...
The scent lasts for quite a long time for an EDT and is still there on the clothes the next day...
The EDP starts with a strong aldehyde mist... *cough*
Immediately a citric-fresh fruitiness also follows with the EDP, but the flowers are still a little late... first the "soap dose" is increased a little bit, which clearly distinguishes the EDP from the EDT... Then follow, although rather discreetly, the ylang blossoms... Also here very nice with a delicate sweetness... But "something" here is a bit biting and sharp... different from the EDT in any case...
Later, the EDP also has a fine woody note, which is not identical to the EDT... In the EDT, the wood is creamy and sweetish soft... The EDP is a bit "harsh" and somehow spicy...
The EDP also lasts quite a long time and is also clearly visible on the clothing the next day...
In summary, I find the EDT to be "rounder", creamier and somehow "more coherent" than the EDP The EDP is very brutal, especially in the beginning, but becomes a bit "nicer" with time... The EDP seems to me almost a bit "madamish" and "mummyish"... The EDT is somehow more cheerful, open and simply "rounder"...
It's a shame, really, that the EDT has been discontinued.
I wouldn't want the EDP on me...
So Chanel and I will probably remain just "nice friends"...
"Chanel is cult, must have" - "Chanel is modern, and must have" - "Chanel is famous, must have" --- No, you don't... ;-)
Nevertheless, it happened recently that a very nice person brought Bois des Îles ("BdI") to my attention and gave me the opportunity to test and compare the EDP and the EDT (of which the production was unfortunately discontinued). Many thanks at this point :)
After I have tested both versions extensively, I would like to tell you about my 1:1 comparison:
Left the EDT and right the EDP.
The EDT starts bright, citric-fruity and with delicate and soft-sweet ylang flowers
Strong, but not pushy. slightly "soapy" but not "old-fashioned"...
... little by little creamy-sweet wood sounds join in, soft and yet "palpable"... the fragrance becomes wonderfully creamy, like a 2nd skin... close to the body, but still always there... a tender aura spreads, wonderful...
The scent lasts for quite a long time for an EDT and is still there on the clothes the next day...
The EDP starts with a strong aldehyde mist... *cough*
Immediately a citric-fresh fruitiness also follows with the EDP, but the flowers are still a little late... first the "soap dose" is increased a little bit, which clearly distinguishes the EDP from the EDT... Then follow, although rather discreetly, the ylang blossoms... Also here very nice with a delicate sweetness... But "something" here is a bit biting and sharp... different from the EDT in any case...
Later, the EDP also has a fine woody note, which is not identical to the EDT... In the EDT, the wood is creamy and sweetish soft... The EDP is a bit "harsh" and somehow spicy...
The EDP also lasts quite a long time and is also clearly visible on the clothing the next day...
In summary, I find the EDT to be "rounder", creamier and somehow "more coherent" than the EDP The EDP is very brutal, especially in the beginning, but becomes a bit "nicer" with time... The EDP seems to me almost a bit "madamish" and "mummyish"... The EDT is somehow more cheerful, open and simply "rounder"...
It's a shame, really, that the EDT has been discontinued.
I wouldn't want the EDP on me...
So Chanel and I will probably remain just "nice friends"...
7 Replies