09/29/2020

Susan
Auto-translated
Show original

Susan
Top Review
35
Bus vs. taxi
First of all: I like Chanel 22, I like aldehydes and especially the way Chanel embeds them in a fragrance. The "22" smells aldehyde-flowery and very well-groomed .....the Ylang Ylang I take almost more distinctly than the Lily of the Valley .....in the base the vanilla stands out clearly and gives a pleasant sweetness...... "soapiness" I can't really recognize to my great regret......rather a coarse-grained powderiness......the scent is round, balanced, timeless and "très Chanel"....
But now comes my personal "BUT"......I am a great admirer of the No.5 (EDT)......for my nose (and also my wallet) the two fragrances are too close together to integrate BOTH permanently into my collection .......on the other hand they are different enough to be able to name a clear favourite ......and that is for me clearly the No.5........
While my nose perceives the No.5 as clear, radiant, sparkling and rather cool, I perceive the No.22 as warmer, rather milky, powdery and clearly softer......especially in the base when the vanilla sets in......
Chanel 22 (EDT) is for me the "bus stop", which is within reach, but to which I have to walk first...No.5 (EDT) on the other hand is the "taxi", which picks me up right in front of the door :-)...
But now comes my personal "BUT"......I am a great admirer of the No.5 (EDT)......for my nose (and also my wallet) the two fragrances are too close together to integrate BOTH permanently into my collection .......on the other hand they are different enough to be able to name a clear favourite ......and that is for me clearly the No.5........
While my nose perceives the No.5 as clear, radiant, sparkling and rather cool, I perceive the No.22 as warmer, rather milky, powdery and clearly softer......especially in the base when the vanilla sets in......
Chanel 22 (EDT) is for me the "bus stop", which is within reach, but to which I have to walk first...No.5 (EDT) on the other hand is the "taxi", which picks me up right in front of the door :-)...
16 Replies