I never considered wearing the original Shalimar EDP or EDT. I found it a very specific scent which was vintage, mature and heavily powdery. I am, however, very impressed with the L'art & La Matiere line. I was looking forward to buying
Spiritueuse Double Vanille after finishing a decant of it.
My curiosity was peaked after reading the reviews describing L'essence as having the Shalimar DNA in the background and powder turned down. There were lots of descriptions about the gorgeous vanilla. So I considered, maybe this could be a substitute for SDV? After all, the price was roughly 100 Euro for 90ml - much better than SDV!
This was a semi-blind buy. I had smelled L'Essence and Shalimar EDP side by side in the store. I don't remember if I sprayed them on paper or just smelled the bottle. What I do remember was one of them was pleasant and one of them was a "Oh hell no". Based on the reviews, I knew it was L'essence that was the pleasant one. The more people complained about it not being Shalimar, the more convinced I was that I would like it!
It arrived in the middle of the cold winter. The first spray was full of doubt. It was so dusty. It was like vintage clothes that had been left in a suitcase for 20 years. I found the opening so powdery and was starting to regret buying it. As it dried down, it became less offensive and had a really special character. I had sprayed myself and my sweater. The next day, the scent was still very strong on my sweater and it was gorgeous in the cold of winter. It was warming, it was motherly and elegant. I kept giving it another shot. You know what? After letting it mature in the bottle a couple of months, the vanilla is stronger and it doesn't feel as harsh and dusty in the opening. It's really beautiful. My curiosity for the other Shalimar flankers has been awakened.
Unfortunately, it is a totally different scent than SDV, so I did indeed end up with both! HA.