Top Notes 
Amaretto
Blackcurrant
Rum
Bergamot
Heart Notes 
Amber
Patchouli blossom
Sandalwood
Base Notes 
Labdanum
Siam benzoin
Vanilla
NicheOnly
122 Reviews
NicheOnly
Helpful Review
7
Althair of 2025
Starting on the 1st of September, I will be exclusively covering samples of British luxury brand Boadicea the Victorious for around a month. With that in mind, I set myself the goal of finishing off the last 2025 samples I had on hand, those being the 6 fragrances launched by Sospiro, the brand formerly recognized as being Xerjoff's middle-eastern alternative. This is the last of the 6 samples, but it's actually a lot more than just a sample. As of the 29th of August 2025, Il Padrino ranks as the #1 niche release of 2025 here on Parfumo with 311 ratings and an average rating of 8.9/10. I'm sure I don't need to tell anyone that living up to such a standard is essentially impossible.
For those even moderately versed within the niche market, the profile of Il Padrino will be easy to understand as it primarily offers notes and accords from existing products in the market. Il Padrino opens with a sweet-spicy DNA that is extremely comparable to Initio's hero franchise Side Effect. Tobacco might not be listed, but the combination of woods, ambers and patchouli clearly offers that same feeling with the only discrepancy being Il Padrino's lack of cinnamon. That sweet-spicy DNA is at first opposed by a well-executed fruity contrast, but on my skin, that fruitiness is not as pronounced as it is in the sample vial nor on the strip. I'd say that fruitiness is a bit like the opening on Clive Christian's XXI: Art Deco - Blonde Amber, i.e. it has that dried fruity amber smell with no clear indication of what the fruit is. Comparisons to scents like Red Tobacco and Triumph of Bacchus have some legs, driven by the tobacco-adjacent nuances smelling a bit like product in that realm, but I wouldn't say those are the main comps here.
Deeper into the heart and the dry-down, the little fruitiness that you do get on skin has completely dissipated and the product that we arrive at smells even more like Initio's Side Effect. Everything about it screams Initio, even down to the poorly executed hedione base featured in Side Effect and the amberwoods that Initio has previously utilized in Blessed Baraka. Beyond the 30 minute mark, I'd say the scent doesn't develop any further with the on-skin blending lacking quality, but that is a criticism that I also have for Side Effect so I don't want to make it sound like Il Padrino is alone in not delivering a smooth execution. The performance ratings on the scent are very inflated as I get average-to-moderate sillage with around 8 hours of longevity, but there's one other thing that is even more inflated here: the actual rating itself.
Back in 2023, Parfums de Marly released Althaïr and to this day, Althair is rated highly both on Parfumo and in the general community. However, when Althair came out, the ratings were even more inflated: I notoriously remember the time when Althair was in the same situation that Il Padrino is now as Althair had ~400 ratings on a 9.0/10 rating. I was among the first 100 to arrive at the scene and one of a very few to highlight that the scent itself, a poorly-executed laundry detergent orange blossom & vanilla ice cream combination inspired by Club Black and/or Sculpture, was miles off the true estimate.
Alas, we arrive at an epiphany: as far as the Parfumo community is concerned, Il Padrino is 2025's version of Althaïr. That isn't a criticism of neither scent, but rather the community as a whole, esp. those offering quantifiable assessments. To put it more harshly, the semi-casual audience/community rating fragrances on here is full of useless hacks who think sensationalist coverage of product is a rational approach to rating product. Fragrances feature an overt selection bias - when I started my journey, I assume I would've placed mainstream niche products in the near-flawless tier as well, driven by the conceivable upgrade from mainstream designer. You can only rate something relative to what you've experienced. However, the community on here is at a more advanced stage than any day-one beginner and with that come expectations for objective coverage, especially since the broader fragrance community (read: influencers) has a tendency to abuse ratings. Ultimately, I find myself wondering whether the people on here are actually making any progress in their fragrance journey, allowing them to find product that is actually flawless or near-flawless, or if they are still stuck in the same beginner stage that I was in approx. 5 years ago.
For those even moderately versed within the niche market, the profile of Il Padrino will be easy to understand as it primarily offers notes and accords from existing products in the market. Il Padrino opens with a sweet-spicy DNA that is extremely comparable to Initio's hero franchise Side Effect. Tobacco might not be listed, but the combination of woods, ambers and patchouli clearly offers that same feeling with the only discrepancy being Il Padrino's lack of cinnamon. That sweet-spicy DNA is at first opposed by a well-executed fruity contrast, but on my skin, that fruitiness is not as pronounced as it is in the sample vial nor on the strip. I'd say that fruitiness is a bit like the opening on Clive Christian's XXI: Art Deco - Blonde Amber, i.e. it has that dried fruity amber smell with no clear indication of what the fruit is. Comparisons to scents like Red Tobacco and Triumph of Bacchus have some legs, driven by the tobacco-adjacent nuances smelling a bit like product in that realm, but I wouldn't say those are the main comps here.
Deeper into the heart and the dry-down, the little fruitiness that you do get on skin has completely dissipated and the product that we arrive at smells even more like Initio's Side Effect. Everything about it screams Initio, even down to the poorly executed hedione base featured in Side Effect and the amberwoods that Initio has previously utilized in Blessed Baraka. Beyond the 30 minute mark, I'd say the scent doesn't develop any further with the on-skin blending lacking quality, but that is a criticism that I also have for Side Effect so I don't want to make it sound like Il Padrino is alone in not delivering a smooth execution. The performance ratings on the scent are very inflated as I get average-to-moderate sillage with around 8 hours of longevity, but there's one other thing that is even more inflated here: the actual rating itself.
Back in 2023, Parfums de Marly released Althaïr and to this day, Althair is rated highly both on Parfumo and in the general community. However, when Althair came out, the ratings were even more inflated: I notoriously remember the time when Althair was in the same situation that Il Padrino is now as Althair had ~400 ratings on a 9.0/10 rating. I was among the first 100 to arrive at the scene and one of a very few to highlight that the scent itself, a poorly-executed laundry detergent orange blossom & vanilla ice cream combination inspired by Club Black and/or Sculpture, was miles off the true estimate.
Alas, we arrive at an epiphany: as far as the Parfumo community is concerned, Il Padrino is 2025's version of Althaïr. That isn't a criticism of neither scent, but rather the community as a whole, esp. those offering quantifiable assessments. To put it more harshly, the semi-casual audience/community rating fragrances on here is full of useless hacks who think sensationalist coverage of product is a rational approach to rating product. Fragrances feature an overt selection bias - when I started my journey, I assume I would've placed mainstream niche products in the near-flawless tier as well, driven by the conceivable upgrade from mainstream designer. You can only rate something relative to what you've experienced. However, the community on here is at a more advanced stage than any day-one beginner and with that come expectations for objective coverage, especially since the broader fragrance community (read: influencers) has a tendency to abuse ratings. Ultimately, I find myself wondering whether the people on here are actually making any progress in their fragrance journey, allowing them to find product that is actually flawless or near-flawless, or if they are still stuck in the same beginner stage that I was in approx. 5 years ago.
IllParagraph
NicheOnly
Patj1994
Scentgazmoe
Andres0719
Orangefreeze
DevilJuice
3aloosh
atllogix
Chataw
