The Tragedy of Lord George 2016

The Tragedy of Lord George by Penhaligon's
Bottle Design:
Marc Ange, Illustration: Kristjana S Williams
We may earn a commission when you buy from links on our site, including the eBay Partner Network and Amazon.
Ranked 95 in Men's Perfume
8.1 / 10 1300 Ratings
A popular perfume by Penhaligon's for men, released in 2016. The scent is spicy-woody. It is being marketed by Puig.
Pronunciation Compare
Similar fragrances
We may earn a commission when you buy from links on our site, including the eBay Partner Network and Amazon.

Main accords

Spicy
Woody
Sweet
Fougère
Creamy

Fragrance Pyramid

Top Notes Top Notes
SoapSoap RumRum
Heart Notes Heart Notes
Tonka beanTonka bean
Base Notes Base Notes
AmbroxAmbrox

Perfumer

Videos
Ratings
Scent
8.11300 Ratings
Longevity
7.41134 Ratings
Sillage
7.01138 Ratings
Bottle
9.21126 Ratings
Value for money
6.2770 Ratings
Submitted by OPomone, last update on 08/19/2025.
Interesting Facts
The fragrance is part of the Portraits collection.

Smells similar

What the fragrance is similar to
Tragedy by Fragrance World
Tragedy
Noble George by Prive Zarah / Zarah
Noble George
304 Cumin Fleur d'Amandier Cèdre by Bon Parfumeur
304 Cumin Fleur d'Amandier Cèdre
Luna Rossa Black by Prada
Luna Rossa Black
Amber pour Homme (Eau de Toilette) by Prada
Amber pour Homme Eau de Toilette
Rossopompeiano by Agatho
Rossopompeiano

Reviews

37 in-depth fragrance descriptions
4
Pricing
10
Bottle
5
Sillage
6
Longevity
9
Scent
Elysium

889 Reviews
Elysium
Elysium
Helpful Review 9  
Brandy Oloroso Viejo Solera Gran Reserva
Anyone who has thoroughly explored a liquor store has likely seen bottles with the word "solera" sprinkled on the label. Suppose the aging solera system is a foreign concept to you. In that case, it's easy enough to understand, primarily if you paint a picture of the process in your head. A solera system involves rows of barrels stacked on top of each other. The lower row of barrels, called the solera, contains the spirit that has aged the longest. When it comes time to bottle some of that spirit, it's taken from this lower row of barrels, say about a third of the content. Then, part of the liquid from the row above is transferred to the barrels of the rows below. And so on, up to the upper barrels, filled with brand new un-aged spirit. The complete system can develop, and the process repeats itself repeatedly.
But what does the solera method have to do with this perfume? Simple. There is a woody alcoholic mention of brandy among the ingredients, which releases intensely during the bouquet's opening. This aged brandy accord immediately made me think of the expensive bottles of liqueur produced with the solera method. Changing the subject, I started my Penhaligon journey with "Trade Routes Collection - Agarbathi | Penhaligon's" a few months ago. I recently had a little bit of luck and bought Lord George decant blindly, only for the presence of distilled and soapy accords. Was it worth it? Absolutely yes. Would I do it again? Yup! And I'll explain why.

As soon as I spray it, I let the greenish juice melt with my skin, and a wave of cask liquor aroma slowly unfolds. It is the impression of a warm, mature, and luxury brandy aged in American oak barrels; I imagine a Cardenal Mendoza, Lepanto Oloroso Viejo, or a Carlos "I" Solera Gran Reserva. Other than the nuances above, what struck me the most is not listed on any of the websites or immediately on the Penhaligon website. And that thing is woody, and not just a hint, a good amount. A nice dry note, somehow fumy, maybe cedar? The underlying woody nuance is dry, smoky, woody, very close to the aroma of pencil shavings. When the initial booze bomb subsides - it's almost gone in the first few minutes - the scent takes a turn that I'm sure I've encountered before. I'm not surprised at how much I like this one. I think it might have something to do with the barber vibe, particularly early on. It has a kind of creamy sweetness, which could be tonka, and it certainly isn't cloying.

Lord George is a stunning modern twist on a classic fougére. While wearing it, something sharp about it reminds me of pelargonium. Still, overall, the scent is very woody and sweet. It's like a geranium leaf floating in an aged brandy glass. The fresh soapiness of neroli paired with sweet, sexy, and smoky undertones from tonka beans provides just the right amount of depth and intrigue. When that distinctive flavor lingers and mixes with the drink, then it's at your fingertips. Soap is like barber foam, the one my father made every morning by dipping the shaving brush first in hot water and then in the soap bowl. Just think of cutthroat razors and old-fashioned aftershave in the best possible sense of the word. It is chiefly delivered, and there is no question for me that anyone wearing it exudes class. The more the perfume enters the intermediate phase, the clearer the resemblance to Amber pour Homme Eau de Toilette the original before reformulation. The two smells share the same soapiness and dustiness. It is precisely the cologne I had in mind when I first smelled the smell. From this moment on, however, it is as if we were at a crossroads: the two perfumes each continue on their path, moving further and further away from each other without ever finding each other again.

As it dries, it gets slightly less creamy and soapy and a little more amber and musky, and miserably that drydown happens sooner than I'd like. It is a sweet amber with salty and musky undertones. And this sweet, boozy amber lingers on my skin for hours and hours. The base of the booziness and soapiness is a soft tonka biscuit that hints at a dark caramel or molasses, with a hint of freshly baked bread.

My final word, success. An exquisitely blended cocktail of alcoholic, amber, and woody nuances. From the first note of perfume comes an overwhelming sensation of splendor and luxury. It is precise of the aristocracy, which takes you to the days of luxurious royal concerts, luxurious palaces, and classical music, as if you were among the guests at that elegant ceremony, at that moment. This perfume blends elegantly and profoundly on the skin; it is pretty linear, although it goes through three distinct phases: alcoholic, soapy, and mushy during its growth. While it may be a little overwhelming at first, it soon becomes something more pleasant, a scent closer to the skin, intimate. I don't get great longevity and not even a ton of projection. But I don't mind at all. Traditionally leaning towards the masculine flavor, I find myself attracted to the fresh, soapy, and sweet notes that develop over time on my skin. A perfect partner to wear from day tonight. However, if you want to layer it on any other oriental woody scent, it doesn't clash in the slightest. I should reserve this fragrance for the best, preferably in the evenings, although the longevity could be better. The fragrance is surprising, rich, dark, smoky. I would have no problem wearing it in the office, on a date, or just around town. Just don't go to the club with it.

I base the review on a decant I have owned since November 2021.

-Elysium
6 Comments
7
Sillage
5
Longevity
6
Scent
Kurai

388 Reviews
Kurai
Kurai
Helpful Review 6  
Tonka bomba
Holy tonka moly! That is one beautiful tonka blast for a top note! Impressive. The next phase of warm-boozy tobacco-amber is a bit too alpha-male for me, but I admit the quality is good. Pretty soon everything dissolves into tonka-ambrox nothingness, only vaguely reminding one of the opening notes.

This does not last long enough to function as a date night scent for youngsters wanting to smell mature and classy, but scent-wise that is how I would classify it.
2 Comments
5
Pricing
5
Bottle
6
Sillage
4
Longevity
1.5
Scent
Ursaw

153 Reviews
Ursaw
Ursaw
5  
Soap taste testing as a modern torture method
Reminded me more of tequila – fun and lovely for the first 5 seconds, but then you blink and suddenly taste asphalt with your face. Not a great time.

I did love the initial cloud! The first whiffs of rum were delightful. And then nigh immediately soap hit me like a brick. Just pure soap. Gigantic dreadful cloud of it. And then it got in my mouth. And then my mouth was sewn shut with the full bar of soap still inside of it.

It truly felt like a tragedy, I'll give them that. It was so bad for the first ~20 minutes that I genuinely wanted to cry. The smell was overwhelming and there was no getting away from it. It felt like every breath I took went through my nose and landed directly on my tongue. A thin soapy film of regrets. For a moment I contemplated finding Alberto Morillas and resorting to violence.

It did eventually fizzle out a little. After the first ~30 minutes it settled closer to my skin and tonka bean came to the forefront. Don't get me wrong, it still tasted like soap, just... less obnoxiously so. And sweeter. Vanilla, but wrong and very inedible.

The sweetness somehow made it worse. Like it was my fault. I wouldn't think to taste test normal bland soap, but vanilla flavored? It felt like I was 12 again and living with consequences of my actions.

It mellowed out over the next 3 hours and eventually faded away completely. But while it did become less overtly soapy as time went on, the weird inedible aftertaste in my mouth lingered.

I think I might just be too sensitive to ambroxan? Horrible way to find that out, but hey, at least each day with this hobby I learn something new!
1 Comment
2
Pricing
9
Bottle
4
Sillage
5
Longevity
7.5
Scent
DrDre10

29 Reviews
DrDre10
DrDre10
3  
Spicy Ivory soap
Let me start by saying this is not a bad fragrance at all. I actually think it's pretty decent. Not the best and certainly not the worst. Not groundbreaking either. The main player in this fragrance from beginning to end is the soap note. Initially, you get ivory soap and some spiciness. IDK why the pyramid has rum listed as a note because it's completely non-existent. Then after about a half hour, the Tonka starts to creep in. THAT'S IT for the next 5 hours..... Tonka and ivory soap with the ivory soap as the dominant player over the Tonka. You really have to pay attention to get a whiff of the Tonka. All-in-all, The Tragedy of Lord George should NEVER be purchased at full price. Buy discounted. Spicy Ivory soap in sprayable form. You will smell clean and properly bathed guaranteed.
3 Comments
Reddawks

69 Reviews
Reddawks
Reddawks
4  
So british...
A fragrance so British it doesn't even get asked for its passport at the border.
A fragrance so British that the Kingsman casting director turned it down, claiming it would steal the show from the real star (Colin Firth’s suit).

When I sniff the cap, a vivid image strikes me: I smell a perfume — not just any perfume, but an Earl Grey tea.
A tea so British that... well, you get the idea.
This impression lingers on the skin, but only for a few seconds.
Then the woods arrive, followed by the bright cleanliness of ambroxan, all wrapped in a dark, almost mysterious vibe, carried by a rather unusual tonka bean accord.

Insta: switzer_scent
0 Comments
More reviews

Statements

29 short views on the fragrance
BertolucciKBertolucciK 5 years ago
10
Bottle
7
Sillage
7
Longevity
8.5
Scent
Spicy, lavender/soap, tonka bean. Barbershop, a bit creamy and sweet. I don't smell any Brandy. Manly, elegant, not for younger people.
0 Comments
OmnipotatoOmnipotato 1 year ago
9
Bottle
7
Sillage
7
Longevity
1
Scent
The most "old man" smell I've ever experienced. Rancid cloying old-fashioned soap with unappealing sweetness
0 Comments
kijimikijimi 7 months ago
Exceptional. Smells like a well-groomed aristocrat. A warm shave with a straight razor and a snifter of brandy.
0 Comments
BoBoChampBoBoChamp 5 years ago
10
Bottle
7
Sillage
8
Longevity
8.5
Scent
A creamy, yet slightly boozy, clean and soapy spicy/sweet Fougère, balanced by a warm and gentle animalic earthy-woody base. Very elegant.
0 Comments
Bernard82Bernard82 3 years ago
Sweet barbershop kind of scent. Lovely done.
0 Comments
ScentToolboxScentToolbox 8 months ago
10
Bottle
5
Sillage
7
Longevity
10
Scent
The king of soapy accords with a dark, patriarchal and slightly mysterious edge. This tells a story on skin but lacks sillage beyond 90 mins
0 Comments
BodomicBodomic 2 years ago
9
Bottle
3
Sillage
4
Longevity
6
Scent
Mass appeal irrelevant scent, unfortunately. No rum, fake fougère, and tonka & ambroxan napalm. Luxury-bottled designer fragrance.
0 Comments
Michael5050Michael5050 11 months ago
One of my favorite perfume bottles, a unique design
0 Comments
TheBloffTheBloff 3 years ago
7
Bottle
6
Sillage
6
Longevity
8.5
Scent
Soapy, clean, barbershop-like scent with a light sweetness. A transportive scent to the far past.
0 Comments
NinamariahNinamariah 12 months ago
9
Bottle
7
Sillage
7
Longevity
5
Scent
Generic barbershop scent, no Rum, no Tonka, only woods + spicy aroma from Ambrox. Designer like, not worth of the price. Very synthetic.
0 Comments
More statements

Charts

This is how the community classifies the fragrance.
Pie Chart Radar Chart

Images

36 fragrance photos of the community
More images

Popular by Penhaligon's

Halfeti by Penhaligon's Sartorial by Penhaligon's The Blazing Mister Sam by Penhaligon's Changing Constance by Penhaligon's Luna (Eau de Toilette) by Penhaligon's The Bewitching Yasmine by Penhaligon's The Omniscient Mister Thompson by Penhaligon's Much Ado About the Duke by Penhaligon's Artemisia (Eau de Parfum) by Penhaligon's Blenheim Bouquet (Eau de Toilette) by Penhaligon's Juniper Sling by Penhaligon's Babylon by Penhaligon's The World According to Arthur by Penhaligon's Endymion by Penhaligon's Malabah (Eau de Parfum) by Penhaligon's Halfeti Leather by Penhaligon's Roaring Radcliff by Penhaligon's The Uncompromising Sohan by Penhaligon's Lothair by Penhaligon's The Coveted Duchess Rose by Penhaligon's