Log in

We may earn a commission when you buy from links on our site, including the eBay Partner Network and Amazon.

Spirit of Black Magnolia

7.0 / 10 42 Ratings
A perfume by Spirit for women. The release year is unknown. The scent is floral-sweet. It is being marketed by Lifestyle Fragrance & Beauty.
Compare
Similar fragrances
We may earn a commission when you buy from links on our site, including the eBay Partner Network and Amazon.

Main accords

Floral
Sweet
Creamy
Powdery
Woody

Fragrance Pyramid

Top Notes Top Notes
FrangipaniFrangipani White blossomsWhite blossoms Ylang-ylangYlang-ylang
Heart Notes Heart Notes
AmberAmber MuskMusk
Base Notes Base Notes
Cashmere woodCashmere wood CedarwoodCedarwood VanillaVanilla
Ratings
Scent
7.042 Ratings
Longevity
6.734 Ratings
Sillage
6.534 Ratings
Bottle
6.335 Ratings
Value for money
8.931 Ratings
Submitted by Duftelinchen · last update on 01/12/2026.
Source-backed & verified

Smells similar

What the fragrance is similar to
Narciso (Eau de Parfum Ambrée) by Narciso Rodriguez
Narciso Eau de Parfum Ambrée
Oriana by Parfums de Marly
Oriana
Spirit of Cashmere Musk by Spirit
Spirit of Cashmere Musk

Reviews

4 in-depth fragrance descriptions
FunnySunny

20 Reviews
Translated · Show originalShow translation
FunnySunny
FunnySunny
Helpful Review 7  
Smelling it for the first time is great...
Yesterday I was at the drugstore and wanted to get some new deodorant. After recently becoming aware of Narciso (Eau de Parfum Ambrée), I actually wanted to test this fragrance. However, I hadn't encountered it yet. But I had also heard about this Spirit of Black Magnolia, which is said to be a dupe for it, and since I am generally drawn to anything with Ambrée or similar hints, I thought I might as well give it a try...

I grabbed a test strip from the container, sprayed the tester on it, and there it was, a WOW effect. A floral-fresh scent, although I'm not quite sure why it’s called Black Magnolia. Frangipani, Ylang-Ylang, and a floral undertone immediately rush in at the beginning. This is then accompanied by musk and woody notes that make the fragrance feel soft. And then it just fills everything around me. It is very present, very intense. I like intense fragrances, so it was allowed to come along.

Back in the office, I of course took the opportunity to apply it right away. And just a few minutes later, I regretted it. It smelled better on the way here than it does now in this small room. After 10 minutes, it becomes a horror. I can only smell floral sweetness. It’s simply everywhere. It has trapped me. And I desperately try to gasp for air, but I’m choking in a sea of flowers. What have I done? Well, let’s just wait a little longer. It doesn’t cost anything, it surely won’t last long, and maybe it will become more pleasant... Not a chance. The scent is impossible to get rid of. And indeed, it reminds me of other fragrances by Narciso Rodriguez. Not in scent, but in its essence. No more perfumes with floral top notes for me. I simply cannot tolerate it.

The fragrance itself is really very present for a long time - at least for me. And unfortunately, I don’t like it at all. I must say, though, that it’s not badly made. It doesn’t smell like a cheap drugstore scent. It’s actually quite potent and lasts a long time. Those who enjoy floral fragrances and are looking for intense scents should definitely give this one a sniff.

Conclusion: Not for me, but I know that floral fragrances and I are not friends. I just ignored it again and am to blame for being dissatisfied now. Whether it is comparable to Narciso, I still cannot answer. But it is certainly just as much of a scent bomb as the fragrances I know from the line. Only this one simply comes off as too floral.
0 Comments
GirlofNow

126 Reviews
Translated · Show originalShow translation
GirlofNow
GirlofNow
Very helpful Review 15  
Great little gem for a small price!
Do you know that feeling?
You go to the drugstore because you only need two things and come back home with 10 things :D And that's how it always is for me...
On Friday, I wanted to quickly stop by the drugstore after shopping to get hand cream and body lotion, and as it goes for a fragrance enthusiast, I absolutely MUST quickly test the perfume section...
And suddenly, I've discovered something that appeals to me and I'm struggling with myself whether I should get it...? Unfortunately, yes...
Since I also like to test affordable fragrances, my eye fell on the new Spirit scent that recently arrived at the drugstore I visit.
So I took a test strip and sprayed it on, and surprise, I liked it... :D
To be honest, when I saw Black Magnolia, I thought it wouldn’t work out for us, but I was wrong.
Better said, the name is misleading...
Well, I was pleasantly surprised by how good it smelled and at an unbeatable price...
So without thinking too long, I took it, paid for it, and went home satisfied :D
Let me describe this scent :)

The scent:
It doesn’t start with Magnolia, but with Mango :D
But with a honey-sweet mango note, and I must say I like it because such scents are always welcome for me in summer :D
Ylang-Ylang develops very creamy and also sweet.
On my skin, it has a hint of sunscreen with a slight Monoi touch, and I love that too!
It is a sweet fragrance, but not a cloying or synthetic sweet scent; rather, I would say it’s a very airy fragrance that is hard to overdo.
I perceive vanilla at the very end, especially when the scent gets close to the skin.
Okay, I admit it has neither good longevity nor outstanding sillage, BUT since it only cost 5.00 Fr., I like to spray it on again for a refresh or just take it with me in my bag.
I must say I liked the scent immediately upon first testing, and I am satisfied with it and will probably use it a lot more in summer as it puts me in a good mood :)
The scent screams summer! :D

2 Comments
Eriele

327 Reviews
Translated · Show originalShow translation
Eriele
Eriele
6  
Sentence with X
Based on the rather positive reviews, I bent down the other day and picked up the fragrance. It was also on sale and then an additional 10% discount. Of course, there was no tester included, and for the mini price, I took the risk of a blind buy.

So... that was a sentence with X, and I can't understand the good reviews. I've always found the company Spirit lacking. I buy fragrances based on my nose and not the price. But here, bending down really isn't worth it. It feels forced and poorly executed.

The beginning is humid, floral, and very synthetic. Those are supposed to be the white flowers. Well, that's how it is. A bit of musk and cashmere wood and something in that direction, but everything feels jagged, not rounded. Creamy, sweet, and powdery is not what I get. It remains a synthetically humid, strange thing with slightly sweaty undertones. For me, it's a candidate for a migraine.

Next time, I'll prefer to look around at other companies.

I pulled a similarity to Narcisso out of thin air.

Longevity is about 10 hours. For those who like the scent, it's a nice thing.

The bottle is simple and suitable for a handbag.
2 Comments
Bascoco11

59 Reviews
Translated · Show originalShow translation
Bascoco11
Bascoco11
Top Review 12  
Beautifully Powdery
This very affordable fragrance is located at the bottom of the perfume shelf in the drugstore, among the discounted items. But as it is in life - bending down can definitely be worth it :)
The 30 ml bottle is, as with all Spirit Of fragrances, very handy and simple. The new packaging is commendable. Only cardboard without plastic now. The cardboard packaging, featuring pink magnolias on a black background and gold lettering, is really very appealing.
The sprayer is also of good quality.
The perfume itself starts off quite alcoholic. Yes, I can only agree, for the first while it smells somewhat unbalanced and quite synthetic. Definitely wait for the first half hour. Once the white flowers have dissipated, a noble powdery musk begins to unfold its effect, supported by amber and woods. This is the phase where this fragrance reminds me a lot of Narciso Poudrée and Ambrée. It somehow lies in between. In the drydown, it resembles Poudrée more for me.
Spirit of Black Magnolia certainly does not match the sillage and longevity of Narcisos, but it smells really good and quite high-quality. I find this truly remarkable given the very low price. Moreover, it definitely still has its own character.
On me, it lasts between 3 and 4 hours. At no point do I get too much of the perfume, and I am genuinely surprised by the good price-performance ratio.
2 Comments

Statements

13 short views on the fragrance
3 years ago
17
Friends, this is a really nice dupe for Narciso Rodriguez Ambrée. Top/Heart/Base compared and practically identical! I think it's great!
Translated · Show originalShow translation
0 Comments
13
First half hour was so-so. From the heart note, I noticed Narcisso DNA. (Ambrée, Poudrée) Surprisingly good musk note. Price-performance: enormous!
Translated · Show originalShow translation
0 Comments
9
5
This scent has nothing to do with Black Magnolia. However, with frangipani and ylang, it's a lovely summer fragrance for everyday wear.
Translated · Show originalShow translation
5 Comments
9
8
The start is quite dense for me, but the base is a musk wood dream! Absolutely successful.
Translated · Show originalShow translation
8 Comments
8
1
Has nothing to do with magnolia at all.
Ylang and frangipani create a creamy and sweet relationship with musk and vanilla.
Translated · Show originalShow translation
1 Comment
8
Strongly floral - mainly synthetic white flowers (lily of the valley, O-flowers?) and ylang. Once it settles, it becomes increasingly sophisticated.
Translated · Show originalShow translation
0 Comments
6
For this price, a really nice scent! Reminds me a bit of Monoi and sunscreen. H+S is okay but still a fine fragrance! :D
Translated · Show originalShow translation
0 Comments
3 years ago
6
1
I really didn't expect black magnolia to be like this. I've definitely smelled it before. I just can't remember where.
Translated · Show originalShow translation
1 Comment
3
Beautiful creamy-sweet frangipani scent. Smells like sunscreen & vacation. I notice slightly synthetic undertones, which are a bit bothersome.
Translated · Show originalShow translation
0 Comments
3 years ago
3
Softlan almond milk, scratchy-powdery + Narciso Rodriguez musk = really not my thing.
Translated · Show originalShow translation
0 Comments
More statements

Charts

This is how the community classifies the fragrance.
Pie Chart Radar Chart

Popular by Spirit

Spirit of Cashmere Musk by Spirit Spirit of Romantic Love by Spirit Spirit of Creamy Coconut by Spirit Spirit of Tempting Lilies by Spirit Spirit of tender secrets by Spirit Spirit of Delicate Blush by Spirit Spirit of Wild Roses by Spirit Spirit of White Vanilla by Spirit Vanilla Wonders by Spirit Spirit of Graceful Beauty by Spirit Spirit of Joyful Blossoms by Spirit Spirit of Cherry Blossom by Spirit Spirit of Fizzy Tangerine by Spirit Spirit of Violet Kiss by Spirit Spirit of Golden Vanilla by Spirit Spirit of Golden Blush by Spirit Spirit of Blooming Delight by Spirit Spirit of Velvet Bouquet by Spirit Spirit of sensual desire by Spirit Spirit of Joyful Splash by Spirit