
bhanna
13 Reviews

bhanna
1
Dream sweet in oud major
With fragrances that have a part I, II, III, etc, I find it most interesting to write about what makes the editions unique. I've already written a separate review on Tonkin Dream for those interested.
While some remade fragrances occur years after the original, Tonkin Dream V2 came out fairly quickly in response to the huge influx of demand for V1. Eric has said that this and Tonkin Rose are two of his most requested fragrances from new enthusiasts.
Frankly, I think this short turn around is the ONLY way this fragrance could exist. The concept of creating a traditional perfume structure of top/mid/base notes with only dense ouds and musk blended is incredible and highlights the perfumer's intimate knowledge of his material. However, it's also why Tonkin Dream can never be recreated again.
V2 benefits from including many of the same oud oils, and shares much of its profile with the original. The blending of musks and ouds in both versions gives me this feeling of relaxation like my brain is getting a massage.
The waxy fruity floral opening of the beginning is toned down slightly but instead feels coated in dense sugary warmth.
The extra musk and slightly different ouds gives V2 an overall darker and heavier feel, but this goes a long way in further boosting the projection compared to the original. Both have excellent longevity as one might expect from a bottle containing 4+ grams of oud oils.
Honestly, even with a gun to my head I'd be hard pressed to pick which version is my favorite.
While some remade fragrances occur years after the original, Tonkin Dream V2 came out fairly quickly in response to the huge influx of demand for V1. Eric has said that this and Tonkin Rose are two of his most requested fragrances from new enthusiasts.
Frankly, I think this short turn around is the ONLY way this fragrance could exist. The concept of creating a traditional perfume structure of top/mid/base notes with only dense ouds and musk blended is incredible and highlights the perfumer's intimate knowledge of his material. However, it's also why Tonkin Dream can never be recreated again.
V2 benefits from including many of the same oud oils, and shares much of its profile with the original. The blending of musks and ouds in both versions gives me this feeling of relaxation like my brain is getting a massage.
The waxy fruity floral opening of the beginning is toned down slightly but instead feels coated in dense sugary warmth.
The extra musk and slightly different ouds gives V2 an overall darker and heavier feel, but this goes a long way in further boosting the projection compared to the original. Both have excellent longevity as one might expect from a bottle containing 4+ grams of oud oils.
Honestly, even with a gun to my head I'd be hard pressed to pick which version is my favorite.



Borneo oud
Mysore sandalwood
Tonkin musk
Vanilla




Christscents
Piopne



































