
MrHonest
121 Reviews

MrHonest
1
Yesssss....THAT'S the one....
Love me a good cherry accord and I was hoping it'd be different enough from Lovely Cherie/Forbidden Love to not be redundant...but it really is just a slight mod. Whereas LC/FL is really a fruity floral with a clear rosy marzipan base (I have the original TF bottle-style release), this one cuts the rose entirely, darkening up the cherry a bit with a LIGHT woody character and a really cool wispy smoke in the mid. In fact, despite the cherry accord being darn near identical to LC/FL, it was the absence of that rose that made this the layering fragrance I was originally hoping for.
What makes this one stand out however, is just how the smoke is done. Unlike some woody fragrances that basically go nuts on the cade or tar (I'm looking at you T-Rex), the smoke in this is done JUST right, reminding me of something you'd sense if some distant part of your house was burning. Instead of it being straight up carbon smoke which has that dark, sooty and woody character like from a campfire, this one is more white, transparent, sheer and almost humid at the back of the throat if that makes any sense. It's also very subtle compared to TF's Cherry Smoke - which I always preferred over the original Lost Cherry. True, there's some booziness missing in the opening that you get with LC/FL, but after that it's basically all cherry, and just as synthetic as its predecessor.
Fortunately, that's exactly what I was hoping for. Even on paper, that cherry accord hangs on and on, never going into the floral direction, while dialing down the marzipan a bit. The woods aren't super strong either, but just enough to give the cherry some body, making it a wonderful choice for layering in the cool weather. True, it's likely that most will consider it a more masculine-leaning release, but I still think it's perfectly unisex thanks to the overwhelming dark fruitiness and perhaps even a touch of powder. And best of all, it's dirt cheap if you can find it.
No qualms about the bottle, atomizer or cap, which clicks into place; and the foam at the bottom of the box that the bottle sits in is far tighter than in LC/FL so there's absolutely no issue with scuffing. Gotta say, I'm a fan. Performance is very decent too, perhaps even slightly better than LC/FL, potentially because of the stronger and longer lasting cherry. But like I mentioned, cutting some of the booziness also makes it less syrupy and more on the woody side. Bit candied too. And does it remind me of Cherry Smoke? Yup. Is it the same? Nope. The TF pushes the smoke forward and the cherry accord is darker; but given the price difference, the contrast in quality is to be expected. I certainly prefer it over LC/FL though. For now it seems, I've found my cheap 'n' cheerful layering cherry of choice. A thumbs up!
What makes this one stand out however, is just how the smoke is done. Unlike some woody fragrances that basically go nuts on the cade or tar (I'm looking at you T-Rex), the smoke in this is done JUST right, reminding me of something you'd sense if some distant part of your house was burning. Instead of it being straight up carbon smoke which has that dark, sooty and woody character like from a campfire, this one is more white, transparent, sheer and almost humid at the back of the throat if that makes any sense. It's also very subtle compared to TF's Cherry Smoke - which I always preferred over the original Lost Cherry. True, there's some booziness missing in the opening that you get with LC/FL, but after that it's basically all cherry, and just as synthetic as its predecessor.
Fortunately, that's exactly what I was hoping for. Even on paper, that cherry accord hangs on and on, never going into the floral direction, while dialing down the marzipan a bit. The woods aren't super strong either, but just enough to give the cherry some body, making it a wonderful choice for layering in the cool weather. True, it's likely that most will consider it a more masculine-leaning release, but I still think it's perfectly unisex thanks to the overwhelming dark fruitiness and perhaps even a touch of powder. And best of all, it's dirt cheap if you can find it.
No qualms about the bottle, atomizer or cap, which clicks into place; and the foam at the bottom of the box that the bottle sits in is far tighter than in LC/FL so there's absolutely no issue with scuffing. Gotta say, I'm a fan. Performance is very decent too, perhaps even slightly better than LC/FL, potentially because of the stronger and longer lasting cherry. But like I mentioned, cutting some of the booziness also makes it less syrupy and more on the woody side. Bit candied too. And does it remind me of Cherry Smoke? Yup. Is it the same? Nope. The TF pushes the smoke forward and the cherry accord is darker; but given the price difference, the contrast in quality is to be expected. I certainly prefer it over LC/FL though. For now it seems, I've found my cheap 'n' cheerful layering cherry of choice. A thumbs up!
Updated on 08/20/2026





jsp
Basti87
Exodusdicio
Heartfire
Sylwanna








































