See Prices

More

We may earn a commission when you buy from links on our site, including the eBay Partner Network and Amazon.

Milk- Commodity 2021

7.5 / 10 112 Ratings

A popular perfume by Commodity for women and men, released in 2021. The scent is sweet-creamy. It is still in production.
Pronunciation Compare

More

We may earn a commission when you buy from links on our site, including the eBay Partner Network and Amazon.

Main accords

Sweet

Creamy

Woody

Gourmand

Synthetic

Fragrance Pyramid

Top Notes

Marshmallow

Roasted sesame

Heart Notes

Mahogany wood

Tonka bean

Base Notes

White cedar Musk

Musk

Perfumer

Christelle Laprade

Ratings

Scent

7.5112 Ratings

Longevity

7.187 Ratings

Sillage

6.087 Ratings

Bottle

7.178 Ratings

Value for money

6.859 Ratings

Submitted by Tesla · last update on 11/02/2025.

Source-backed & verified

Smells similar

What the fragrance is similar to

Milk

Milk+

Intimate Silhouette

Bianco Latte

Sunny Side Up

Santal Blanc

Reviews

12 in-depth fragrance descriptions

04/16/2025

Geenamariiie
4 Reviews

Geenamariiie

Helpful Review 2

Not as sweet as expected

I bought this on a blind buy because I'm obsessed with marshmallow and sweet scents. This wasn't as sweet as expected. I know it's a unisex scent but I feel like it leans more masculine. I'm thinking of giving it to my boyfriend who's also a gourmand lover. I definitely don't see myself ever reaching for this.

01/17/2025

Scentalgias
18 Reviews

Scentalgias

2

Milk-

Reminds me of baking rice krispy squares during Christmas with my mom as a kid, licking the sticky marshmallow off of a wooden spoon.

First sample in the Commodity Exploration Kit I’m reviewing and I personally LOVE this scent. It’s a very light gourmand scent that is like a mix of marshmallow and cashmere with a slight woody note. It lasts for hours but isn’t over powering. No toothaches here! It’s light enough that I would throw this into a regular daily rotation for sure. This makes me super excited to try the rest of this kit

03/11/2025

4.5Scent 7Longevity 4Sillage

HelloFriend
16 Reviews

HelloFriend

1

Sugary Sweet Marshmallow

Working through the Commodity Milk strengths, I find that Milk- is probably the most cloyingly sweet of the Milk line. I actually like Milk Expressive, it's a bit more dynamic and layered and there's a bit more to it than "super sweet lactonic marshmallow". Unfortunately, this is just what Milk- is.

First spray, I pick up a milky marshmallow crusted in sugar, like those cartoon character shaped ones you find wrapped in plastic at carnivals and malls. It wouldn't be so bad if they toned down the sweetness a bit, but this was the kind of sugary that almost felt gritty on the nose. It had no restraint, and I was unfortunately unable to smell any of the roasted sesame or woody notes that may have tempered it a bit.

This smell lingered for a good while, at least... but unfortunately for me, by hour 1 or 2, I felt like I needed to at least rinse my wrist with water because I could feel a headache developing. It still lingered faintly the next morning, so it's a good, long lasting fragrance and the sillage at least stayed pretty intimate.

08/30/2024

9.5Scent 2Sillage

Lupusliz
6 Reviews

Lupusliz

1

Cozy Comfort

This is the ultimate comfort fragrance. The sillage is intentionally weak (I can't yet speak to the longevity), so I find myself often lifting my wrist to my nose to enjoy the scent. This is a fragrance I'll wear to bed, as well as casual occasions when I want a non-imposing scent.

I'm testing it over a vanilla amber body lotion, so I think it would layer very well with any fragrance that is vanilla and/or amber forward.

09/28/2025

7.5Scent 8Longevity 6Sillage

cyninge
14 Reviews

cyninge

1

A good vanilla gourmand to have

When I first purchased a travel size of this perfume I found it pleasant and fairly straightforward: a sugary vanilla grounded by some subtle woodiness. To be totally honest, I bought it because I'd heard good things and also heard that men tend to respond well to vanilla perfumes on women, and I was about to start dating again and wanted a nice but not groundbreaking date fragrance. Recently, after letting it sit mostly unused for over a year (dating is hard, okay?), I tried it again and was struck by a strong smoky overtone in the opening. Suddenly it wasn't just sweet vanilla, but unmistakably a marshmallow charred over a wood fire. It's still very sugary, and it's not like it magically turned dark and dramatic, but either the perfume itself or my perception of it has a little more oomph and edge now.

I liked how it smelled at first sniff, but I like how it smells to me now even more. It seems stronger as well, so I had to pull back the amount I use. Whether or not other people experience the same change over time, I think Milk- is a good choice if you are looking for a sweet vanilla gourmand with just enough going on to keep it interesting. It has good staying power and decent projection even though it's billed as the "personal" version of the Milk fragrance. I haven't tried the others, so I can't say how it compares to those.

More reviews