Milk by Commodity
We may earn a commission when you buy from links on our site, including the eBay Partner Network and Amazon.
7.1 / 10 329 Ratings
A perfume by Commodity for women and men, released in 2021. The scent is sweet-creamy. It is still in production.
Pronunciation
We may earn a commission when you buy from links on our site, including the eBay Partner Network and Amazon.

Main accords

Sweet
Creamy
Gourmand
Woody
Synthetic

Fragrance Pyramid

Top Notes Top Notes
MarshmallowMarshmallow Roasted sesameRoasted sesame
Heart Notes Heart Notes
Tonka beanTonka bean Mahogany woodMahogany wood
Base Notes Base Notes
BenzoinBenzoin MilkMilk

Perfumer

Ratings
Scent
7.1329 Ratings
Longevity
7.6268 Ratings
Sillage
7.0269 Ratings
Bottle
7.2255 Ratings
Value for money
7.1212 Ratings
Submitted by Franfan20, last update on 07/26/2025.

Smells similar

What the fragrance is similar to
Milk+ by Commodity
Milk+
Intimate Silhouette by Christian Siriano
Intimate Silhouette
Milk- by Commodity
Milk-
Crushed Velvet by A.N Other
Crushed Velvet
Sissa by Mind Games
Sissa
6 | Six by Valjues
6 | Six

Reviews

22 in-depth fragrance descriptions
6
Pricing
5
Bottle
10
Sillage
8
Longevity
6
Scent
KathrynA66

46 Reviews
KathrynA66
KathrynA66
Helpful Review 5  
For Marshmallow Lovers
On me, this opens with an absolutely luscious sweet cream note, so cozy. I wish it lasted a little longer, but the marshmallow develops very quickly. It is a very realistic marshmallow, sweet, fluffy, not to heavy. This was a solinote on me for a long time. I really didn't get any noticeable musk, just a bit of powder with the marshmallow. I found it a bit dull, but if you love marshmallow, you might love it. Still, this is not a linear fragrance. The tonka and mahogany notes bring a richness and depth to the fragrance. On me, it turned into a very strong pipe tobacco accord, which some people would absolutely love, but it's not for me. I do appreciate how this develops on my skin, and I think it is well done.

The fragrance lasts for hours, and be careful applying because the projection is monster strong. My husband came in from another room to ask if I was smoking a pipe! Although some people think this leans feminine, but I disagree. I found the dry down rather masculine, which is fine with me. I think anyone who likes marshmallow should at least test this, but it is not a good idea to blind buy.
0 Comments
4
Pricing
4
Bottle
3
Sillage
3
Longevity
3
Scent
Jayvicmay

94 Reviews
Jayvicmay
Jayvicmay
Helpful Review 3  
What is this??
I was so excited for this fragrance from how everyone raves about it. How it is this sweet, creamy, soft, milky, marshmallow heavy fragrance… this is straight up mens cologne. It is very very woody and spicy. I smell like the men in my family with this on. Where is the milky marshmallow everyone speaks of??
0 Comments
8
Longevity
6.5
Scent
Sugarylemon

57 Reviews
Sugarylemon
Sugarylemon
4  
Well.....
I'm definitely in the minority here, but I didn't like this nearly as much as I thought I would. I get ZERO marshmallow and ZERO milk notes after spraying this on my skin. It's cozy, yes, but I don't get any of the notes other people are smelling.

To me, it just smells like smoky, musky wood with a hint of sweetness. It kind of smells like a candle. I feel like maybe I would like it better if I layered it with something else. I don't absolutely hate it, but I'm pretty underwhelmed with what I'm smelling. I really wanted to smell something lactonic lol.

I will say the longevity is pretty good, though! It lasted a good 6-7 hours on my skin.
0 Comments
10
Pricing
10
Bottle
9
Sillage
10
Longevity
9.5
Scent
Whimssysteph

13 Reviews
Whimssysteph
Whimssysteph
3  
so this is love
This isn't something I would have guessed I would like based on just looking at the note pyramid, but I got a sample and fell so in love. It is creamy, rich, a little nutty, with some almost spicy woodiness layered in. I usually go for scents that are more overtly feminine, but I think this one is very truly unisex and would work for a variety of people. On me it is sweet but definitely not overtly so. To me, it is much more aromatic than gourmand. It layers nicely, and, best of all, it lasts all day and into the night on my skin. Definitely one of my best fragrance purchases in a very long time, and I will happily keep this as part of my collection.
0 Comments
5
Pricing
6
Bottle
4
Sillage
6
Longevity
7.5
Scent
LavenderSalv

37 Reviews
LavenderSalv
LavenderSalv
3  
Is it just me?
I cannot be the only person on this website actually getting the notes the perfume box says it's supposed to have. To me this evokes the (admittedly weird) image of eating a piping hot s'more around a campfire, but I have a cold glass of milk with me for some reason. Overall it's quite nice and better suited to summer nights than I could imagine.
0 Comments
More reviews

Statements

21 short views on the fragrance
Cass0014Cass0014 2 years ago
8
Sillage
9
Longevity
5
Scent
I love marshmallows and didn’t really get a smell I loved out of this fragrance. It is strong to the point of overwhelming.
0 Comments
PurpleKatPurpleKat 2 years ago
7
Bottle
8
Sillage
4.5
Scent
On my skin this is overpoweringly sweet roasted marshmallow with burnt wood and a weird medicinal note that bothered my nose. Not great!
0 Comments
CeesieCeesie 7 months ago
Beautiful creamy sweet milk. Does what the title says.
0 Comments
SirrysclosetSirryscloset 11 months ago
4
Bottle
7
Sillage
7
Longevity
3
Scent
It smells like burned marshmallow cough syrup on my skin. I think it might be the mahogany note…not sure but I was disappointed.
0 Comments
TaylorBeeTaylorBee 4 months ago
8
Bottle
7
Sillage
8
Longevity
8.5
Scent
Very woody, slightly spicy, cereal milk. It's super sweet but not too heavy.
0 Comments
SniffwhiffSniffwhiff 5 months ago
6.5
Scent
I don't get milk? Woody & spicy. Sweet marshmallow-y dry down. Strong. Leans masculine but turns unisex in drydown. Smells best next day
0 Comments
NuteNute 7 months ago
7
Bottle
10
Sillage
10
Longevity
9.5
Scent
Adore this. Marshmallow is one of my favorite notes, and this one does it best (or maybe Delizia by Kyse for some occasions).
0 Comments
MeadhbhMeadhbh 2 years ago
Like the crispy, burnt part of a toasted marshmallow mixed with fresh cream
0 Comments
mikbmikb 1 month ago
1.5
Scent
Instant pickle juice on my skin - and I LOVE the other two Laprade seasame fragrances, Sissa and Intimate Silhouette. This ain't it
0 Comments
markeisimonmarkeisimon 1 month ago
5
Bottle
6
Sillage
7
Longevity
8
Scent
Very reminiscent of CH Amythist Haze or Replica's Coffee Break but at a much better price point. Powdery, woody marshmallow.
0 Comments
More statements

Charts

This is how the community classifies the fragrance.
Pie Chart Radar Chart

Images

2 fragrance photos of the community

Popular by Commodity

Gold by Commodity Milk+ by Commodity Milk- by Commodity Book by Commodity Moss by Commodity Moss+ by Commodity Velvet by Commodity Bergamot by Commodity Paper- by Commodity Juice by Commodity Gold- by Commodity W*****y / Whiskey by Commodity Orris by Commodity Rain by Commodity Gold+ by Commodity Paper by Commodity Vetiver by Commodity Moss- by Commodity Nectar by Commodity Book+ by Commodity