Log in

Create Account Forgot your Password?
7.7 307 Ratings
A popular perfume by Commodity for women and men. The release year is unknown. The scent is sweet-spicy. It is still in production. The perfume is vegan according to the manufacturer.
Pronunciation Compare Vegan
Similar fragrances

Main accords

Sweet
Spicy
Woody
Creamy
Resinous

Fragrance Pyramid

Top Notes Top Notes
Juniper berryJuniper berry
Heart Notes Heart Notes
VanillaVanilla SandalwoodSandalwood
Base Notes Base Notes
BenzoinBenzoin MuskMusk AmberAmber

Perfumer

Ratings
Scent 7.7
307 Ratings
010
Longevity 6.8
235 Ratings
010
Sillage 6.2
233 Ratings
010
Bottle 7.1
203 Ratings
010
Value for money 6.7
157 Ratings
010
Submitted by AmyAmy, updated on 08/31/2026
Source-backed & verified
Interesting Facts
The fragrance is part of the Scent Space: Expressive collection.

Smells similar

What the fragrance is similar to
The Architects Club by Arquiste
The Architects Club
Gypsy Water (Eau de Parfum) by Byredo
Gypsy Water Eau de Parfum
Eau Duelle (Eau de Parfum) by Diptyque
Eau Duelle Eau de Parfum
Gentle Fluidity (Gold) by Maison Francis Kurkdjian
Gentle Fluidity (Gold)
Eau Duelle (Eau de Toilette) by Diptyque
Eau Duelle Eau de Toilette
Black Tie (Eau de Parfum) by Celine
Black Tie Eau de Parfum

Reviews

16 in-depth fragrance descriptions
Luckymommy

57 Reviews
Luckymommy
Luckymommy
Helpful Review 4
Instant love!
This was one of those love att fist sniff perfumes for me. It just feels so comforting with its almost burnt sugar, warm spicy vanilla and creamy woody goodness, it reminds me of something from my childhood but I can't put my finger on it. It's just love, instant love.
A full bottle is on my wishlist.
0 Comments
Martah22

9 Reviews
Martah22
Martah22
3
Creamy Sexy Vanilla Musk
This is one of my favorites from Commodity. I love Milk as well. It is a unisex scent leaning a bit masculine. It's warm, mellow, sweet and creamy. I pick up on the vanilla, sandalwood and musk. I brought the sample I had on a trip with me and sprayed it in front of my teenage daughter. She immediately asked me what it was because she liked it. She asked if I could spray some on her too before we went out to dinner.
0 Comments
ScentStudio

159 Reviews
ScentStudio
ScentStudio
1
Expressive Gold
On paper, I am met by a gorgeous scent, but I'm also experiencing déjà vu. Gold has the same scent profile as Milk and Velvet. Sweet, creamy, warm. That in itself is quite anticlimactic. Don't get me wrong, the fragrance is gorgeous, but I have been smelling something similar for the last couple of days.

So how is it on the skin? Hopefully like Velvet, very different from on paper.
Oh yes, on skin there is a fresher minty note at top (the juniper berries). It evaporates after a minute, but it lingers after the scent has dried down.

A couple of minutes in and I almost cannot smell it anymore. What is it in Commodity fragrances that is so incompatible with my chemistry?

I love the contrast of the juniper with the warm, sweet vanilla and amber, but to experience it, I have to reapply it many times within just half an hour!

I honestly thought my choice would be a battle between Milk and Gold, but reaching back in my memory, I am leaning more towards Velvet and Milk.

Gold is a wonderful fragrance if you can smell it.
However, my Commodity journey was supposed to finish with a bang, but it ended up with a fizzle.
0 Comments
Mavila16

45 Reviews
Mavila16
Mavila16
1
Woody Amber, not Green Vanilla
This is one of those perfumes that likely smells completely different on everyone, but on me it’s not vanilla at all, just a straight up amber with some wood. And amber can be a tricky note, some days it’s extremely potent, huge sillage, sickly sweet and gives me a headache. And then other days it completely disappear and I can’t smell a thing. I don’t know if it’s hormonal, the weather, or what the reason is, but that inconsistency makes it a very difficult fragrance to wear, despite it being a super simple composition. Please test before buying, I for one am grateful I only have a travel size.
0 Comments
cupcakegirl

34 Reviews
cupcakegirl
cupcakegirl
1
liquid luxury
i love this a lot. the vanilla and amber go so well together with the benzoin and sandalwood , so warm and cozy and perfect for a cold winter day. reminds me of bare vanilla by victoria’s secret a lot on the dry down. perfectly encapsulates how gold would smell like. sweet and sexy. yes it has some similarities to other fragrances but this just entices me in the best way
0 Comments
More reviews

Statements

63 short views on the fragrance
3 months ago
My diabetic grandfather's sugar-free vanilla bean ice cream he always offered but I never wanted.
6
0 Comments
This is what I wanted Milk to be!! Sweet, warm, comforting. Light spice if I smell my wrists up close.
2
0 Comments
4 months ago
Creamy vanilla sandalwood. Feels pretty typical (generic?) for a vanilla-forward scent
2
0 Comments
11 months ago
Creamy vanilla, musk, and amber, with just a hint of juniper. A straightforward fragrance, but a beautiful one.
2
0 Comments
secretly better than milk (more for me)
1
0 Comments
More statements

Charts

This is how the community classifies the fragrance.

Images

3 fragrance photos of the community

Popular by Commodity

Milk by Commodity Milk+ by Commodity Milk Orchid by Commodity Milk- by Commodity Moss by Commodity Book by Commodity Juice by Commodity Moss+ by Commodity Velvet by Commodity Gold- by Commodity Ice(d) by Commodity Paper- by Commodity Bergamot by Commodity Rain by Commodity Paper by Commodity Gold+ by Commodity Moss- by Commodity Orris by Commodity W*****y / Whiskey by Commodity Wool by Commodity