06/15/2012
Greysolon
74 Reviews
Greysolon
Critique Very helpful Review
7
Recipe for a vanilla caramel 2 X 4
Normally I have stories for the fragrances I write about. For Rochas Man I got...
...nada.
After reading loads of favorable reviews I happened to see Rochas Man on sale at a discount store, so I bought it. I've tried it numerous times since and I still can't understand all the enthusiasm.
When you first apply Rochas Man it's big, over the top, syrupy and vanilla caramel sweet. As it dries down the only thing that changes is that it's not as big and over the top but just as syrupy sweet. Then, as Rochas Man dries down further, wood comes through. Except it's not the sandalwood listed in the notes. It's more like freshly cut 2 X 4 lumber. That's about it, a vanilla caramel scented 2 X 4. Aside from the woodiness it's very similar to Givenchy Pi. Pi is roundly disparaged so why does Rochas Man catch a break?
Oh, and the bottle? Not to be indelicate but, well, you know...
Addendum: Sherapop noted in her comment to my review that many people think of Rochas Man as a coffee scent. Since I hadn’t mentioned coffee at all she wondered if I found it wanting in that regard. Before I wrote my original review I had scanned through other reviews but I couldn't recall coffee being mentioned. So I made a search of “best coffee fragrances” and, of course, Sherapop is right: Rochas Man appears frequently as a popular coffee fragrance. So I reapplied Rochas Man, tuned my inner nose to coffee and... I dunno... maybe I could get to coffee if it were a super sweet, milk laden caramel cafe latte. And I may be willing to concede that what I called the sawn “2 x 4” wood accord might be coffee notes interacting with other essences. Maybe? Ultimately my overriding impression is still sweet, vanilla caramel. I wouldn’t count on Rochas Man for my coffee fix.
...nada.
After reading loads of favorable reviews I happened to see Rochas Man on sale at a discount store, so I bought it. I've tried it numerous times since and I still can't understand all the enthusiasm.
When you first apply Rochas Man it's big, over the top, syrupy and vanilla caramel sweet. As it dries down the only thing that changes is that it's not as big and over the top but just as syrupy sweet. Then, as Rochas Man dries down further, wood comes through. Except it's not the sandalwood listed in the notes. It's more like freshly cut 2 X 4 lumber. That's about it, a vanilla caramel scented 2 X 4. Aside from the woodiness it's very similar to Givenchy Pi. Pi is roundly disparaged so why does Rochas Man catch a break?
Oh, and the bottle? Not to be indelicate but, well, you know...
Addendum: Sherapop noted in her comment to my review that many people think of Rochas Man as a coffee scent. Since I hadn’t mentioned coffee at all she wondered if I found it wanting in that regard. Before I wrote my original review I had scanned through other reviews but I couldn't recall coffee being mentioned. So I made a search of “best coffee fragrances” and, of course, Sherapop is right: Rochas Man appears frequently as a popular coffee fragrance. So I reapplied Rochas Man, tuned my inner nose to coffee and... I dunno... maybe I could get to coffee if it were a super sweet, milk laden caramel cafe latte. And I may be willing to concede that what I called the sawn “2 x 4” wood accord might be coffee notes interacting with other essences. Maybe? Ultimately my overriding impression is still sweet, vanilla caramel. I wouldn’t count on Rochas Man for my coffee fix.
5 Comments