Just like its sisters
Guava Granita and
Miami Nectar, Isla Sirena is banking on the whole tropical, sunny getaway theme going on with Ellis Brooklyn's two other scents. It could've been good, great actually, but unfortunately it fell short of my expectations.
I will admit the beginning was very nice. I smelled bananas (I wouldn't be able to tell the difference between a blue Java banana and a normal banana though), papaya and a subtle hint of salt that gave some moment-at-the-beach vibe. It's more during the appearance of the middle notes that the vibe started feeling off. The papaya remained, a juicy, sweet, pulpy fruit as coconut started coming in with a semi creamy, semi aquatic kind of vibe. There was a weird spicy and floral accord (maybe from the ginger flower...?) and some sweet vanilla that mingled in. It's difficult to explain at this point how and why I was turned off. I don't know if it's the ginger flower that clashed with the array of fruits or the salt that marred the vanilla orchid, but something didn't sit well here. As time passed, it started simmering down to a warm, gourmand, creamy and sugary coconut scent (without the sunscreen aspect) with a fleeting undertone of woodiness.
If it wasn't for the middle moment that went wrong, I might have gone for a travel size at least. Unfortunately, something turned out weird on my skin and I didn't like it as much as its other two sisters. If your skin chemistry doesn't betray you, this might be a very lovely vacation scent, great for the upcoming summer. I do suggest you try it out first (thankfully I tried it on at a Sephora before blind-buying it... I've learned my lesson, ha!).