LOOKING FOR SWEET, WOODY perfumes based on my favs:

Im looking for more fragrances. Here are my favorites:

- Eilish (original) by billie eilish

- Le Monde Gourmand Hazelnut L’Hun

- Mix:Bar Vanilla Bourbon

-finery Sweet on the Outside

- sol de Janeiro Cheirosa 62 Brazilian crush

- replica by the fireplace (although I like the sweet part of it more than the wood smoke part)

And different type of scent but:

- Glossier You

Dior Bois talisman is pretty similar to by the fireplace. If you like that, you should like bois talisman too. Its like sweet/smokey wood. Not my personal favourite though but check it out

Krea

Woodcut Not sure if it will have the same effect for you but on me it was right in the middle of woody and gourmand/sweet in a very pleasant way. It does have a bit of a green resin start if that is a deal-breaker for you.

Absolue d'Osmanthe Eau de Parfum I smelled it on the back of my hand today and in the drydown, it is a soft kind of sweetness (not syrupy, more of a dry kind of sweetness) and it is woody, unisex in the opening, more feminine leaning in the drydown.

Another take on You Eau de Parfum is Fleur de Peau Eau de Parfum with the latter more classy (and it should be, given the price ) I LOVE it, but find it a little ovepriced (170 euro's for 75 ml).

You’ve got a great list—lots of cozy, sweet, and slightly woody scents in there! If you’re looking for more in that vibe, here are a few worth checking out:

🌰 Guerlain - Spiritueuse Double Vanille – A rich, boozy vanilla with warm woods. It’s deeper than Eilish but still very sweet and inviting.

🔥 Kayali - Vanilla Royale Sugared Patchouli 64 – If you liked the vanilla warmth in By the Fireplace but want to skip the smokiness, this has a similar rich, woody sweetness.

🍂 BDK - Velvet Tonka – A beautiful mix of almond, tonka, and woods with a soft sweetness that might be right up your alley.

🥥 Diptyque - Eau Duelle – A spiced vanilla with woody depth, perfect if you want something sweet but not overly sugary.

I totally get why you love the sweet side of By the Fireplace more than the smoke—have you tried Mancera Tonka Cola? It’s got that rich sweetness but skips the heavy firewood note.

Would love to hear what you end up trying next!

I mean if u want a sweet woody, u genuinely have to check out: Féminité du bois Its the classic fruity woody fragrance. Legendary.

@clovermichel have you tried My Happy. - Cookies & Kisses ?

The name is misleading, it's not at all cookies - but rather a sweet woody blend. It's also sometimes compared to Eilish Eau de Parfum and By the Fireplace ! Can test for free at most Ulta stores, since it looks like you're in the US.

And based on the other fragrances you mentioned, you might also enjoy these:
Miel Bourbon
Cozy Vanilla Bourbon
Vanilla Romance Eau de Parfum
Silver Moon Perfume

The best sweet-creamy sandalwood is No. 23 but I'm unsure what happened to its production.