Replica

Whispers in the Library Maison Margiela 2019

Whispers in the Library by Maison Margiela

See Prices

More

We may earn a commission when you buy from links on our site, including the eBay Partner Network and Amazon.

See Prices

7.9 / 10 690 Ratings

A popular perfume by Maison Margiela for women and men, released in 2019. The scent is woody-sweet. It was last marketed by L'Oréal.
Pronunciation

More

We may earn a commission when you buy from links on our site, including the eBay Partner Network and Amazon.

Main accords

Woody

Sweet

Spicy

Powdery

Creamy

Fragrance Pyramid

Top Notes

Pepper

Orange blossom absolute

Patchouli

Heart Notes

Benzoin Siam

Tonka bean absolute Cypriol

Cypriol

Base Notes

Vanilla absolute

Cedarwood

Vetiver

Videos

Watch video

Ratings

Scent

7.9690 Ratings

Longevity

6.8595 Ratings

Sillage

6.3591 Ratings

Bottle

8.0576 Ratings

Value for money

7.1413 Ratings

Submitted by BeyondTheSea, last update on 03/07/2025.

Interesting Facts

The fragrance was part of the collection "Replica".

Smells similar

What the fragrance is similar to

Far Away Royale

Metal Wave

Spice Blend

Leather Skies

Vanilla & Cedarwood

Babylon

Reviews

29 in-depth fragrance descriptions

02/03/2022

4
Sillage 8
Longevity 9.5
Scent

RisingChaos
109 Reviews

RisingChaos

3

Vanilla Paper

This opens with a somewhat musty vanilla, which airs out to something slightly more musky and airy over the course of a few minutes. As if I opened an old book, covered with a gentle layer of dust and filled with crinkly stale paper, and watched it slowly transform into a new, glossy magazine. The best way I can describe this is it smells like a bucket of wet wood pulp splashed with vanilla extract, lacquer, and a dash of black pepper. Papery, woody, with an air of gentle sweetness. Moderately soft projection for 2-3hr, longevity 9-11hr.

11/11/2024

Alexlinhcao
101 Reviews

Alexlinhcao

2

Whispers in the Library

Truly a lackluster experience. I'm so happy to hear that there are devotees for this fragrance, but it couldn't be me. There are some scents which I wouldn't wear, but can still admire on it's own or for someone else. WITL is neither of these for me.

The wear of it is poor (under an hour) and the fragrance profile itself isn't particularly pretty. I get a lot of a liniment-ish/ Carmex note in the beginning which I'll guess is somewhere between the patchouli and benzoin. But after that, it quickly fades to a watered down vanilla, if even that.

I don't get a cozy, vanilla-wood. I don't get books or a library. I don't get dark academia. For all of these things, I find there are much better options. I'm so glad I didn't blind buy this one after hearing it was discontinued from the REPLICA line. While I hate the name Autumn Vibes, it far exceeds in what WITL is trying to do.

01/02/2025

7
Pricing 10
Bottle 8
Sillage 8
Longevity 10
Scent

FlowerFiend3
4 Reviews

FlowerFiend3

2

My Favorite Fragrance of All Time!

This is my signature cold-season scent.

It opens with the must of a sun-filtered library, dustmotes floating in the slight breeze of an open window.

It settles into vellum, ink, and leather at the heart. The feeling of spending hours doing research in ancient, heavy tomes at a worn wooden desk.

And oh so subtly, it morphs into the base notes of a hearth, a slight smoky accord to compliment the squashy leather chair before the fireplace, in which you sip your tea and read your saga of a novel in a quiet evening.

I quite literally cried when they discontinued this one, and I'm hoarding the last bottles I can find.

06/10/2023

Rosymel
122 Reviews

Rosymel

2

Pretty vanilla but too fleeting and soft

I like the notes in this one—vanilla and tobacco mostly—but goodness me what a soft performer. Even within five minutes of spraying it, I had to get my nose right up to my skin to smell it.

I generally have a light hand when spraying any perfume, extra light if I’ve been warned it’ll be a beast. I am usually a one spray and done type of person, so I find it funny when people talk about spraying themselves four or five times, because generally that would leave me gasping for air and overwhelmed with fragrance. But this? I think I’d need at least four or five sprays to smell it at all after a few minutes! It’s odd when I compare it to the other Replica scents I’ve tried (I have the Discovery sample set); they tend to be very good performers. For example, I have applied Music Festival VERY lightly and still smelled traces of it for the next three days on my jacket.

As for the actual scent itself: I can see where the library connotation comes in, because I find old books (and the real wooden bookshelves they tend to sit on) do have a kind of sweet, woody aroma. My grandma had a lot of her father’s books from the 1800s and early 1900s in her attic, and this is kind of how her attic smelled. It brings back nice memories for me. But yeah, the longevity is so fleeting I would never buy a bottle of it. The sample I have will have to suffice.

08/20/2023

8
Pricing 8
Bottle 7
Sillage 8
Longevity 10
Scent

Scentgorlie
15 Reviews

Scentgorlie

3

College Nostalgia

It feels like a breezy fall day, studying for midterms on campus. Super nostalgic from my college days. A bit spicy and slightly sweet woody and resinous scent that smells smooth and relaxing.

It’s as if Jazz Club and Killian Straight to Heaven had a baby. Jazz Club is creamier, StH is way spicier, but in the same vein. If you like fragrances that are like this — a sweet yet spicy woody vibe — give this one a try if you can find a sample.

I really love this one a lot and I’m super happy to have found a bottle being that it’s discontinued. I purchased off of Scents Angel with discount code CHRIS15

More reviews