This was so close to being a hit for me. After working my way through most of the Kayali line in hopes to find a partner for my beloved Vanilla 28, I picked up a full bottle of Eden Juicy Apple. I happily sprayed, and fell completely in love...until about half an hour later and it started to dry down. Then there was this weird, off scent that just smelled...dirty on me. Thought it was a mistake or a one off, so I kept trying, and trying. And trying. And I kept loving the first half hour, and feeling like I needed a good bath after that. Shudder. I am so tempted to revisit and use it exclusively as a layering scent. Maybe. Probably. Sigh.