Do you remember the Amouage before COVID? It might feel like a distant memory, but in the aftermath of the pandemic as Amouage's house direction continues to go more and more mainstream, the gap between what the Omani brand does now relative to where they were under Chong or even in Renaud's first few years has never been bigger.
Decision is yet another example of that gap widening.
Review written off 1 wear with an official sample I got from Jovoy.
One aspect that I dislike about contemporary Amouage's creative direction (or the lack thereof) is the heavy cross-application of notes/accords from product to product. If you were to read my review of
Reasons which came out in 2024, you'd see me highlight how the scent uses many of the raw ingredients from scents like
Lineage and
Jubilation XXV Man. The same was true of
Lustre and the same is also true with
Decision.
On my first time smelling
Decision, the initial notes that I wrote down state that Decision features the same sweet licorice-like opening of
Opus XIV - Royal Tobacco, the same spicy notes like
Lineage, the same aromatic-synthetic woody structure like
Purpose with a very clear reference to one-trick-pony Quentin Bisch's akigalawood DNA. The actual transition of the scent is smokier and when I first smell the scent up-close, there is a prominent woody tonality contrasted by moderate smokiness.
Decision smells a bit like woods charring next to a live campfire with the atlas cedar having a light leathery quality to it as well. In the ultimate dry-down around ~1.5-2 hours in, the scent leans more heavily into the various notes & accords visible in both
Lineage and
Purpose as the smokiness/depth dissipates into a mild spicy-woody scent with aromatic quality.
Overall, there's just nothing special about
Decision overall as the composition is very simple in nature once all the other notes fade away after the top. The various parts of
Lineage and
Lustre that I can smell in the dry-down are mild-to-moderate with the core scent being a one-two of atlas cedar and incense. I'd say this scent is woody-smoky-spicy with some resinous/leathery qualities. Performance wise it feels average: I am not getting anything more than average sillage, but I'd expect this to be in the 7-8 hour range for longevity (which I'd rate as a 6). The blending and execution are the only things pushing this above a median ranking, but besides that there really isn't anything else here.