Replica

Afternoon Delight 2024

Afternoon Delight by Maison Margiela
We may earn a commission when you buy from links on our site, including the eBay Partner Network and Amazon.
6.4 / 10 52 Ratings
A new perfume by Maison Margiela for women and men, released in 2024. The scent is gourmand-sweet. It is being marketed by L'Oréal.
Pronunciation
We may earn a commission when you buy from links on our site, including the eBay Partner Network and Amazon.

Main accords

Gourmand
Sweet
Creamy
Spicy
Woody

Fragrance Pyramid

Top Notes Top Notes
Bitter almondBitter almond Angelica rootAngelica root
Heart Notes Heart Notes
MadeleineMadeleine Ambrette seed absoluteAmbrette seed absolute CarrotCarrot
Base Notes Base Notes
Bourbon vanillaBourbon vanilla New Caledonian sandalwoodNew Caledonian sandalwood MuskMusk

Perfumer

Videos
Ratings
Scent
6.452 Ratings
Longevity
6.435 Ratings
Sillage
5.735 Ratings
Bottle
7.540 Ratings
Value for money
5.826 Ratings
Submitted by Telekinec, last update on 01/18/2025.
Interesting Facts
The fragrance is part of the "Replica" collection.

Smells similar

What the fragrance is similar to

Reviews

7 in-depth fragrance descriptions
8
Bottle
6
Scent
Telekinec

295 Reviews
Telekinec
Telekinec
2  
Not madeleine; more like a powdery, musky, vanilla, sandalwood fragrance
If there's one perfume that has been (over?)hyped recently, it's this one for sure. As soon as influencers got their hands on it, there were so many comparisons made. Some say it smells like Vanilla Milk, others mention Bianco Latte, Fresh Cream Eau de Toilette and even Vanilla Sex. I'm part of the crowd that thinks it smells like Vanilla Sex and one who won't get a full bottle. Here's why.

When I first heard about it, I thought it'd be a sweet, gourmand, pastry scent, in the same vein as Casamorati - Lira Eau de Parfum or Love & Crime just without the fruity note. When I saw the notes, I did hesitate. I had a feeling the marketing was wrong and the scent would turn out way different.

I was right.

On my skin, bitter almond comes out strong. Strong powdery note, a sprinkle of nuttiness. I can't attest for the angelica root note as I do not know what that smells like, but a research on internet says this note smells green / herbal / spicy and is warm, mapley, and slightly sweet. I do get the spiciness, the warmth and the slight sweetness. I have to say, the powderiness is almost overpowering and too much for me. When I bring it up to my nose, I get this in-your-face powderiness with a kick of spices (almost bitter spices). From farther away, I still get powderiness and spices, but that's when I can smell an evanescent note of carrot (quite fleeting) and some sweet pastry, like the one I can smell in XerJoff or Ex Idolo's interpretation. After a while, I get the sandalwood: woodiness and some sort of creamy aspect. Musk also rises up and vanilla ends up taking its place. I wouldn't say it's a lactonic fragrance, which is why comparisons with Bianco Latte and Vanilla Milk were strange to me, but it does have that bitterness, that powdery nuttiness that's quite similar to Vanilla Sex, while also having that powdery, sweet pastry note I've smelled in XerJoff or Ex Idolo. I've got to say, after a while, the drydown reminded me of Rabbit with that powderiness and slight sweetness mixed with the musk, the sandalwood and the vanilla. Unfortunately, wasn't really my thing because of the strong powdery aspect.

It's not a safe blind-buy for gourmand lovers. If I hadn't fallen to the FOMO and had taken the time to smell it in-store before, it probably wouldn't have made it past this step. I don't hate it, but it wasn't what I was expecting it to be from the marketing. I wanted a sweet, gourmand, delicious, mouth-watering pastry scent (madeleines are so lovely), but instead I got a strong powdery, musky vanilla and sandalwood-forward perfume that's quite far from the madeleine picture I had in mind. Buyers beware.
0 Comments
6
Pricing
10
Bottle
7
Sillage
6
Longevity
8
Scent
VintageWitch

30 Reviews
VintageWitch
VintageWitch
1  
Not quite a hit, but not quite a miss
I love watching perfume reviews on Youtube, for better or worse, and generally take them with a grain of salt regarding fragrances I haven't tried yet. I especially love to test out controversial scents that seem to have the internet frag community torn, which is what has happened with this exact perfume. I was finally able to get my nose on this and properly test this out, and I must say...I'm conflicted. Sorry to say this, but the initial burst of this fragrance hit me with an unpleasant milky, powdery smell which instantly reminded me of infant spit-up (so sorry for that detail). I was a bit taken aback but pushed through until the mid before washing it off. Luckily that stage didn't last long and it began to settle into a fluffy,cakey bakery scent I'm familiar with; it smells like a Madeleine cookie, like the prepackaged ones at Starbucks, and sandalwood. This holds through the rest of the fragrance life, and sits close to the skin. While not a BAD scent, per se, I feel as though I have smelled this before. I have been trying to think of what it smells like, but I know for sure it was a drug-store perfume I would get on occasion in the 90s. I honestly don't dislike this fragrance and find it to be kind of nostalgic because it reminds me of something, which is kind of what the brand is known for, right? However, I'm not sure I could justify the price tag for a full bottle. I know that they already have a coffee themed fragrance, but I feel that this would have been a lot more interesting with a black tea/chai/coffee/etc note accompanied with the notes in this. I will have to try layering this with coffee break and report back if that works together. As far as recommending this or not, I say do not blind buy. Test this out if you can, and not just once, but a few times before deciding. This is an odd one, for sure.

Update: I tested this today with Coffee Break and it works really well! Spray more of Afternoon Delight than Coffee Break for a wonderfully sweet coffee shop scent.
0 Comments
7
Pricing
9
Bottle
7
Sillage
10
Longevity
8.5
Scent
Banjeekundt

97 Reviews
Banjeekundt
Banjeekundt
2  
Madeleines in the sunlight
Based on the relatively polarizing reviews I've seen for this fragrance, I was apprehensive about trying this but I genuinely really enjoyed it.

It starts off sweet, slightly spicy and lactonic, and savory in a buttery and nutty way. There's powdery vanilla, almond, and angelica root apparent at the open. The madeleine note starts emerging about two hours in, bolstering the vanilla and buttery aspect of the fragrance, making it truly delightful. It smells like having cookies with tea in a windowsill while the sunlight streams in—soft, cozy and warmly sweet.

About four hours in, I pick up on the carrot note which adds another interesting layer to the scent—somewhere between sweet, earthy and savory. Then, the vanilla develops into something creamier, losing the powdery quality. After about seven hours, the madeleine and nuttiness completely fade and the sandalwood comes out, turning it into a woodsy vanilla. This lasted for over 10 hours on me.

Overall, I was very pleasantly surprised by this perfume. The scent was better than I'd hoped for and the longevity was sensational for an eau de toilette.
0 Comments
7
Scent
Bythemoon

5 Reviews
Bythemoon
Bythemoon
2  
Delightful and Simple
True to it's name, this is a delightful vanilla pastry that can be interpreted as a madeleine. It kind of reminds me of a flavorful vanilla ice cream or cookies and cream. My first whiff was mouth-watering and I was inclined to purchase a bottle for a short moment, but I got a little tired of it after a while. That may be because I'm generally picky with vanilla. If you're a vanilla person that's looking for something not too complex and easy to wear, this is it.
0 Comments
6.5
Scent
lucekingg

13 Reviews
lucekingg
lucekingg
1  
Fitting Name
This is something I would wear to go get a little treat. It reminds me a lot of Tom Ford Vanilla Sex but there's something in this that ties it all together and I like this a lot more. It's warm and sweet and I found a saltiness that I really enjoy, most of my vanillas tend to run sweet so this adds a little variety to my collection. It does make me feel like I'm eating a pastry outside on a sunny day. This came in a Sephora sampler and I might redeem the voucher for a travel-size version of this.
0 Comments
More reviews

Statements

9 short views on the fragrance
K8SliderK8Slider 5 months ago
Smells like a buttery vanilla cookie, like the ones that come in the sewing kit (iykyk). At the 10 hour mark it's still detectable on my skin.
0 Comments
TelekinecTelekinec 5 months ago
8
Bottle
6
Scent
Marketed as a pastry scent, it's more of a sweet, powdery, musky, sandalwood perfume. Not bad, but I've already smelled that somewhere.
0 Comments
IrisEllaIrisElla 3 months ago
Very vanilla Madeleine but with a touch a musk to make it more sophisticated. Quite nice actually.
0 Comments
Deja1sabelDeja1sabel 1 month ago
4
Scent
raw pancake batter
0 Comments
RjudgeRjudge 2 months ago
light vanilla. Madeline is correct note. Light and fresh vanilla though, not heavy or deep! On me: VERY vanilla extract- and lasts that way!
0 Comments
GeorgeReidGeorgeReid 3 months ago
7
Bottle
6
Sillage
7
Longevity
5
Scent
An almond milk smell, with a musky vanilla and woody base. I like Replica fragrances and gourmands, but this is unappealing to me.
0 Comments
ItscoralItscoral 4 months ago
Yes, it smells like a madeleine, but I also get a VERY strong buttery note that I can't look past. It's a shame because I wanted to love it.
0 Comments
AgegshdhdAgegshdhd 4 months ago
burnt milk
0 Comments
Shaeri87Shaeri87 5 months ago
This is delicious, very impressed with how they created this Madeleine accord. It stays with you throughout the wear, this is a gourmand lovers treat!
0 Comments
More statements

Charts

This is how the community classifies the fragrance.
Pie Chart Radar Chart

Images

2 fragrance photos of the community

Popular by Maison Margiela

By the Fireplace by Maison Margiela Jazz Club by Maison Margiela Whispers in the Library by Maison Margiela Beach Walk by Maison Margiela Lipstick On by Maison Margiela Lazy Sunday Morning (Eau de Toilette) by Maison Margiela (untitled) by Maison Margiela At the Barber's by Maison Margiela Under The Lemon Trees by Maison Margiela Coffee Break by Maison Margiela Soul of the Forest by Maison Margiela (untitled) l'eau by Maison Margiela Sailing Day by Maison Margiela Autumn Vibes by Maison Margiela Bubble Bath by Maison Margiela Matcha Meditation by Maison Margiela When the Rain Stops by Maison Margiela From the Garden by Maison Margiela On a Date by Maison Margiela Music Festival by Maison Margiela Springtime in a Park by Maison Margiela